We chat with some of the engineers at NVIDIA and go behind the scenes of the impressive Quake II RTX mod.
NVIDIA on Quake II RTX as the First Fully Ray-Traced Game
The city builder meets conquest series has been around for many years, and this new entry take the series back to the past to re-capture some magic.
Anno 1800 Review - Going Back to Move Forward
We sit down with Blizzard and the Hearthstone team to talk about what goes into designing a new card set and mechanics.
Talking Hearthstone and the New Rise of Shadows Expansion!
Does it hold up almost a decade after first exploding onto the scene?
Borderlands: Game of the Year Edition Review
Anthem
Anthem

Genre: Third Person Shooter
Developer: Bioware
Publisher: Electronic Arts
Release Date:
February 2019
Anthem Review
Review By @ 03:25pm 25/02/19
PC
Disjointed is probably the best way to describe BioWare’s Anthem; the latest grand sci-fi epic from the Mass Effect, Dragon Age, and veteran role-playing studio. A clear departure, Anthem attempts to fit into what we’ve come to know as the ‘looter shooter’ genre. That style of game where action-RPG mechanics combine with shooter-style action, and players get rewarded with better gear and shinier loot the more they play. Using this cycle as an incentive to head back out into a large online world, alone or with friends, to face new challenges and grow more powerful – long after the story is over. That’s the plan anyway.

How Anthem fits into this mould is strange and confusing because it ultimately fails to embrace or even figure out how to properly merge its two sides. With the first being Anthem’s deep co-op action ambition, an experience driven by progressing abilities and improving gear loadouts of the various playable Javelins at your disposal. The ‘looter shooter’ side. And second, as a brand new BioWare IP that introduces new characters, a new world, and rich story. From the creators of Baldur’s Gate, and so on. One that seemingly will evolve and change over time, in true 21st century fashion. Or, for the more cynical – as a live service.


It’s in that second part where Anthem disappoints the most. The first part is probably the easiest to improve over time. The campaign in Anthem, or journey, is not presented as a big world shared with other players or Freelancers, but instead as a stilted single-player tale told mostly through face-to-face conversations. In that non-playable characters will often stand motionless, talking at you The Chosen Freelancer. With only a handful of sequences that provide genuine cinematic thrill or even notable animation work, Anthem fails to be engaging for most of its ‘save the world’ story.


"The campaign in Anthem, or journey, is not presented as a big world shared with other players or Freelancers, but instead as a stilted single-player tale told mostly through face-to-face conversations."




The illusion of choice is at its most fragile here too, with BioWare’s renown ability to inject morality into its tales a mere inconsequential shadow. Characters both engaging and not have their own stories that progress along the main campaign, but dialogue choices bear no real weight outside of a few minor examples. One of which concerns a potential spy in the game’s main hub of Fort Tarsis. What’s even more disappointing is that this static, lifeless nature of the narrative affects and detracts from Anthem as a co-op action shooter. The good stuff.


Friends or random players in your party during a mission? Voice-less bots for the most part, not essential to your story or even acknowledged narratively. Anthem makes no attempt to weave its online, co-operative, or PvE nature – at launch – into any part of its story. The main city hub of Fort Tarsis is simply not conducive to playing in a group. Everyone sits in their own instance, and due to the sheer number of mostly lifeless conversations to engage in – a squad will never be in sync. An unfortunate outcome that extends to the current repetitive endgame.

It’s baffling, especially coming from a studio known for story. For all the interesting lore and intrigue of the world, most of it is hidden behind layers of library entries that players shouldn’t have to read through. Context-free lore, without following that basic principle of showing not telling. Figuring out exactly what the Anthem is, who the Scar are, the Dominion, not to mention the random names of people and places you’re bombarded with during in-mission chatter requires patience and a willingness to read and take notes. For those delving into this side of Anthem there’s a lot to find, genuinely fascinating stuff too. But, again, only a fraction of it makes its way into the overarching story proper.


For everyone else, Anthem’s story presents the usual stop the big bad from activating the powerful thing. Albeit with a big-bad that features no depth or nuance. Very un-BioWare.


"For all the interesting lore and intrigue of the world, most of it is hidden behind layers of library entries that players shouldn’t have to read through."




The action though, and the Javelin mechanics, are both Anthem’s saving grace. With the fluid movement of the Javelins and the ability-based combat that lets players combo off their own skills or those of their squad offering a brisk and bombastic feel that often feels unlike anything else. In the best possible way. In fact, combat in Anthem places as much emphasis on well-timed ability use as it does shooting – with quick cooldowns and a variety of skills to mix and match. A clear distinction between the various classes of Javelins and the weapons that might suit them best adds incentive to head back out in ways that the story doesn’t.

The elemental Storm class can be played from high-above, hovering and dispensing large fire and ice-based attacks. The Interceptor, runs fast, can triple jump and be used as a melee assassin.


The little details here also impress. With the heat of a Javelin suit dictating how long or high they can fly. Going straight up means a hotter burn, skimming waterfalls will cool you down, and going underwater adds a true sense of awe and freedom of movement. You can also fly longer when it’s raining. But even this part of the experience feels disjointed as it’s broken up by arbitrary barriers and load-screens and a UI philosophy that opts for style over usability or function. A few examples. You can’t place a waypoint on a map, downed squad members are only visible if you notice the tiny icon amid the visual chaos, key mission objectives and challenges can be buried in a sub-menu of a sub-menu of a sub-menu.

Mission design itself lacks ambition, rarely calling on what makes each Javelin feel great to pilot and manoeuvre and call destruction down upon enemies. Like the story, there are a few exceptions and thrilling missions to be found – but overall the structure follows one of two setups. Go collect things and bring them back over here or stay here and defend this spot from hordes of enemies for a few minutes. Now here’s a boss. Enemies also weirdly and almost exclusively spawn in via mysterious relics, separating the moment to moment action from the stunning world you get to explore.


Taking place on the mysterious planet called Bastion, Anthem’s in-game environments are indeed stunning. From ancient overgrown ruins, to giant temples, waterfalls and river-beds, and volcanic lakes, everything is brought together with a verticality that sets it apart from anything you’ve played before. Anthem’s Bastion can make even the most impressive open-world role-playing games with mountainous regions look flat in comparison. It’s a staggering technical achievement too, one that is brimming with life and detail no matter the current time of day or weather pattern.


"From ancient overgrown ruins, to giant temples, waterfalls and river-beds, and volcanic lakes, everything is brought together with a verticality that sets it apart from anything you’ve played before. "




The only downside being that it quickly becomes an embarrassment of riches, with little to offer in the way of variety. And even though there are cave systems, a few large installations, and gorgeous underwater sojourns full of glowing alien wonders – the wonder soon fades. In a way it’s like looking at a fleet of red Ferraris. No matter whether it’s sunny or cloudy or raining, you’ll soon wonder where the other colours might be. The different makes. The biomes. The desert that’s hinted at in Anthem’s lore, the volcanic region limited to a linear level.


Another aspect where Anthem falls short is in the loot and gear stakes - which fails to live up to the more staple trends we’ve seen across the Destiny’s of the world and action-RPGs in general. Without a PvP mode, BioWare has opted to relegate the best and all the genuinely interesting items and weapons to the endgame. But even so there’s no feeling of becoming truly powerful or god-like. For the most part Anthem offers up the same handful of weapons and components to equip for dozens of hours, all with slightly higher numbers. Numbers that fail to communicate meaning due to no stat sheet or in-depth look at your character or Javelin.

Not being able to see just what a blue or purple diamond drop is until you exit the play area, or even switch out a weapon outside of combat are two of many baffling design decisions. When it comes to the loot game, you’re at least three loading screens away from completing even the most basic task.

What keeps Anthem from being a complete misfire, and firmly in the region of ‘good’ is the combat flow and the Javelin mechanics. Something that admittedly kept us actively engaged with Anthem for the duration of the twenty or so hour campaign. The simple act of flying around at notable speed is pulled off so well that you’ll begin to visualise future superhero games borrowing the mechanic outright. This movement and the subsequent ability-based combat goes hand in hand with the brilliant verticality and complexity of Bastion, offering several glimpses into what could have been another BioWare developed classic.


It’s a shame then that everything surrounding this core feels so disjointed. A story that lacks momentum outside of a few moments, mission design that reveals all its nuance in a matter of minutes, and a cumbersome progression system interrupted by walls. The large concrete barrier surrounding Fort Tarsis should feature the inscription – ‘Still Under Construction. Enter to find arbitrary loading screens, hidden menus, key information buried within library entries, and loot that does little to inspire’. A somewhat harsh judgement but one reinforced by the Fort itself, an eerily quiet hub where both the market and bar you visit featuring little more than a few whispers of life. Back to flying then.
What we liked
  • Flight and combat mechanics are fast, fluid, and exciting
  • Combo system works well to create skill and squad synergy
  • Different Javelins not only look, err, different but also offer different play-styles
  • Often visually stunning
  • Javelin customisation is in-depth, colour-wise
What we didn't like
  • Disjointed, with a single-player story and town hub that is lifeless
  • You're always a couple of load screens and sub-menus away from completing basic stuff
  • Loot lacks character and impact
  • Crafting is pointless and not explained properly at all
  • A lot of Anthem is hidden in library entries and figuring stuff out
  • Performance issues across PC and console
More
We gave it:
6.0
OUT OF 10
Latest Comments
dais
Posted 02:03am 26/2/19
What a shame. It looked phenomenal at E3. Is it just me, or is this a case of Electronic Arts having them rush it out the door with things like microtransactions as a priority, to make the big moolah on the hype train?

Here's hoping it turns out like Diablo III (with its real money auction house), with a lot more work put into it to make it a great game, many years after a botched original release.
fpot
Posted 03:13am 26/2/19
BioWare and Bethesda are both in serious peril.
Zapo
Posted 07:05am 26/2/19
I'm actually enjoying the game, far more than a 6/10 which tends to be the general concensus in reviews.

I'm level 22, I think I'm nearing the end of the main story.

I wonder how much of the negativity is EA hate, or Bioware hype? The game isn't perfect, but I'm enjoying it that I would easily recommend it to people +... It was going for $55.

Also dais, there are micro transactions for cosmetic stuff.... I haven't felt the urge to buy anything, and I have spent a lot on dota 2 :)
ravn0s
Posted 09:17am 26/2/19
i was interested in the game until i played it during the beta weekends. what a s*** show of a game.
Khel
Posted 11:35am 26/2/19
Yeah, I'm enjoying it, I think 5's and 6's are pretty unfair, I mean Fallout 76 got 5's and 6's and this is far better than that. Its a flawed game for sure, but I think its a bit of a victim of high expectations, if it wasn't Bioware making it and was just some other studio without that same weight of expectation behind them, I think it'd be a different story.
Vash
Posted 11:52am 26/2/19
What happened to these two awesome game companies?
Bethesda hasn't been bought out by anyone, and perhaps the EA effect f***ed up Bioware.
Murf
Posted 01:25pm 26/2/19
6 years in development..(supposedly) The promise of Bioware quality story, characters and world in a seamless online multiplayer experience...

so yeah that considering I think the scores its getting are very fair
dais
Posted 01:49pm 26/2/19
This is interesting:

Khel
Posted 02:07pm 26/2/19
Anyone who came into this expecting some classic Bioware game was just kidding themselves, the Bioware of old died many years ago. I came in with no real expectations and its fun, its got a fun combat loop, it looks gorgeous, its an interesting world with a lot of interesting lore behind it. Loading screens are too frequent and a bit of an annoyance, and theres nowhere near enough variation in the missions and the enemies you fight (or the loot for that matter), and the UI and general user experience could do with some improvements, but its no worse than Destiny or the Division was at launch. In fact, its quite a bit better in some regards, like the story might not be up to Mass Effect calibre but its still a hell of a lot better than what was in Destiny or The Division or even Destiny 2, and those were getting 7's and 8's and higher.

I mean, they should have really learnt from the mistakes those games made, and not just made the same mistakes themselves, so its not like that excuses their mistakes but I think a combination of general EA hate and disappointment with Bioware are skewing the scores. I don't think its worth 8's but its at least worth 7's imo, maybe a 7.5. Theres fun to be had there, if you can get past the EA/Bioware stigma
Zapo
Posted 04:20pm 26/2/19
The expectations you may have of a game, or a studio shouldn't have any bearing on the rating it gets. You should perhaps be more lenient towards games which are not full priced - but otherwise if the exact game is released by Bioware and El'dogio studios it should get the same rating.

+ What Khel said.
Arpey
Posted 04:56pm 26/2/19
I'm playing and enjoying it for the flying and the combat. The load screens are a real dog, but I've not had any connection troubles which is rare with an online game this early. Story is meh but I like the javelins a lot. Hopefully EA has the guts to do what Ubisoft has done with their online games and work on it until it's better to pull in an audience.
Hunter
Posted 07:11pm 26/2/19
I believe the game needed at least another 6 months development time
Khel
Posted 11:33am 27/2/19
I believe the game needed at least another 6 months development time


Agreed, it definitely would have benefited a lot from another few months of development
trog
Posted 11:41am 27/2/19
man the game in the E3 video dais posted looks awesome
funky
Posted 03:10pm 28/2/19
I've really enjoyed it so far. Finished the single player the other night, will poke around on the strongholds and other content, but I see it is probably going to be a game that I will probably leave for a while and then turn to when there is more story type content, I'm not obsessed with running things over and over again for loot drops, so the frustrations with some of those mechanics don't really affect me too much.
The combat and flying have been loads of fun, I'll probably spend some more time with the other javelin types as well in freeplay and quickplay etc (i went with the ranger first off and i want to give the others more of a go). but I got it for $66 from JB and I'm pretty happy with what I have got from it so far, but I'm more of a casual gamer anyway. I have had maybe one or two instances of glitches with missions, which is apparently pretty great considering the amount of vitriol that has been out there about them
Hunter
Posted 07:58pm 03/3/19
I wish MS (instead of EA) had acquired Bioware back in the day... they were literally an MS Studio anyway during the Xbox/Xbox 360 days...
notgreazy
Posted 09:13am 04/3/19
How are these wicked trailers actually made? Is it real gameplay with CGI added in or do they setup a rail like system ingame, spend time adding in scripted content (like the player shooting and enemies dying), all in-game or do they go all out and just make a completely CGI video?

I've always disliked trailers, teasers etc. It's propaganda showing an idealised version of a game that doesn't exist. Unless you show me actual gameplay footage, in-game, it's nothing more than a cutscene. Unfortunately, they're getting better and better and blurring the lines between what's gameplay footage and what's a movie.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in now!
17 Comments
Show