A challenging and thoughtful experience where lateral thinking and classic Nintendo game-design come together.
Raiders of the Lost Star - Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker Review
We chat with The Division 2 game director, Mathias Karlson, and talk about lessons learnt post-epidemic!
Interview: The Division 2 Does Away with Divisive Game-Design
Set in the 1980s, during the later stages of the Cold War - Phantom Doctrine brings the art of espionage to the world of turn-based tactics.
With Phantom Doctrine You’ve Got XCOM in the Cold-War Era
First Super Mario Odyssey Review Awards it a Perfect Score
Melbourne, Victoria
2871 posts
The first review of Super Mario Odyssey, the spiritual successor to Super Mario 64 has been reviewed and awarded a perfect score by respected and long running magazine Edge. That perfect score? A 10. The issue, which is set to hit shelves around the world tomorrow, was spotted early by some keen magazine stand watchers that noticed the 10/10 score.

Here's a snippet.

After our recent hands-on we were thinking that Super Mario Odyssey could very well be as amazing an experience as Super Mario 64, so this reaffirms that idea. And now we can't wait to delve into the full release.
12:44pm 12/10/17 Permalink
12:44pm 12/10/17 Permalink
Brisbane, Queensland
1011 posts
Games EDGE has given 10/10 to so far (20).

Super Mario 64 (1996)
Gran Turismo (1997)
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998)
Halo: Combat Evolved (2001)
Half-Life 2 (2004)
Halo 3 (2007)
The Orange Box (2007)
Super Mario Galaxy (2007)
Grand Theft Auto IV (2008)
LittleBigPlanet (2008)
Bayonetta (2009)
Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010)
Rock Band 3 (2010)
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (2011)
The Last of Us (2013)
Grand Theft Auto V (2013)
Bayonetta 2 (2014)
Bloodborne (2015)
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (2017)
Super Mario Odyssey (2017)
06:43pm 12/10/17 Permalink
Melbourne, Victoria
9513 posts
So they give out 10s easily. Good to know.

GT, Galaxy, Skyward Sword, GTA4, HL2 - these are not 10/10 games. I'm not even sure Ocarina is. 9.5 sure, but 10? hard sell.
10:08am 13/10/17 Permalink
Brisbane, Queensland
3409 posts
Ocarina isn't a 10? Go f*** yourself :)

Seriously though, I agree with some of your other comments, but Ocarina was so easily a 10, I mean, it could have been a freakin' 11 if that were possible.
10:50am 13/10/17 Permalink
Melbourne, Victoria
9515 posts
LttP is a 10. OOT is like a 9, maybe a 9.5.
09:25pm 13/10/17 Permalink
Gold Coast, Queensland
26072 posts
HL is a timeless classic how can that not be a 10?!?!?!
09:41pm 13/10/17 Permalink
Brisbane, Queensland
1012 posts
Depends what your definition of 10/10 is. Does 10/10 have to be perfect? I don't think so. Nothing would be 10/10 in that case. It has to set a new standard in some fashion or do something better than any game before has done. Perfect a style of gameplay or start a new trend in gaming. Something that other games from then on will try to emulate.

I'm fine with most of that list, but I haven't played them all. Was Rock Band 3 the pinnacle rhythm games? Was Little Big Planet that great a game? I know the Wii controls in The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword were love / hate. But I think most of the other games on that list are pretty universally praised.
10:00pm 13/10/17 Permalink
Melbourne, Victoria
9516 posts
No. A 10 needs longevity. I can come back to LttP every time and still love it. When I go back and play OOT, it's always "oh FFS, I gotta play through this fscking forest temple before I get to the good stuff."

The good stuff in OOT doesn't happen until you pass the first four or five dungeons - and it's annoying to have to play through them every time, like a chore. That's why I don't think OOT deserves a 10 - because it can be not fun to play.

LttP doesn't suffer from that problem - the earlier dungeons are equally good and worth playing.
10:37pm 13/10/17 Permalink
Brisbane, Queensland
3410 posts
Firstly, it's pretty subjective so you're more than welcome to not give it a 10, but I think most people probably did (just sayin').

To me, for a single player game replayability is irrelevant. I'm not at all interested in playing single player games several times over, there are so many f*****' games these days - to go back and play it again after 30-40-50 hours is just not my cup of tea (maybe it's yours). That being said I have played OOT about 2-3 times, including the master quest mode.

It's a 10 in my book, it was a brilliant game.
09:11am 14/10/17 Permalink
Ballarat, Victoria
4330 posts
oh yeah i put a preorder down for one of these recently, looks great: October 29 right?
04:12am 15/10/17 Permalink
04:12am 15/10/17 Permalink
AusGamers Forums
Show: per page
This thread is archived and cannot be replied to.