The car crash in VIC - 5 dead, 1 survived
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4013 posts
I just can't believe anyone survived in this car:
Shortly after the car hurtled through the intersection of Childs Road and Plenty Road at Mill Park, the driver lost control and slid off the road into a large oak tree, the impact splitting the metre-wide trunk in half.
.
.
.
After the fire was out, they could only see the hand and head of the girl in the back and could not tell how many had perished. Veteran paramedic Ron McLeod said even seasoned emergency workers were traumatised by the accident.
''I've been a paramedic for 30 years and and this is the most horrific scene I've ever seen,'' he said.
Chick that survived was 15yo.
It's a pretty weird story of events too: The Age article
For TL;DR people: gatecrashers came to party, guy wanted to move his car cos he was worried about it, gatecrashers tried to force him out of car - he 'sped off in anger' (?) He was pursued for a bit, then it sounds like he was just being totally stupid.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28980 posts
and that's why you don't speed
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11050 posts
yeh stock falcons aren't meant to be going fast
they're just not ready
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3695 posts
Even before I ever drove I knew this is how young drivers die. Car full of wankers + high speed. I actually wish death upon people I see driving like that.
LOL a quote about the memorial at the crash scene the next day:
A man handed around bourbon drinks while others pulled out spray cans and scrawled their grief on the footpath and tree stump.
Sounds like a sensible crowd. last edited by thermite at 11:01:41 18/Jan/10
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5384 posts
I don't, because they've usually got innocent people in the passenger seats
I'm going to teach my kids to put up a fight if they ever find themselves in a situation where the driver is being a lunatic and they can't get out
fucking choke/kick/punch/whatever, just get the fuck out and call teq to /beatdown on the dickhead driver
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5060 posts
so is it speed or (car full of wankers + high speed) that's the problem? there seems to be some uncertainty amongst the qgl know-it-alls. i demand answers!
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3696 posts
innocent my arse, you get into a xr6 with an underage drunk roof tiler who aspires to be a rap-star, that has a recent speeding conviction, with FIVE OTHER PEOPLE, at a party, and then you hang out the window while he speeds along yelling and screaming and carrying on and doing the finger to the drivers behind you, you deserve what you get.
last edited by thermite at 11:06:56 18/Jan/10
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2542 posts
I think it's:
car full of wankers + high speed + falcon + strong opinion = bad news...
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11051 posts
so is it speed or (car full of wankers + high speed) that's the problem? there seems to be some uncertainty amongst the qgl know-it-alls. i demand answers!
yeah I've never had a problem with speeding
I realise that if I do have a problem with control of the car or someone else losing control of their car near me, there might be more chance of injury or death the faster I'm/they're going. but there's more chance of dying if I walk out my front door than not too. crossing the road is pretty dangerous compared to not crossing the road as well. in fact, just being alive increases the chance of death.
and that's why you should never live
|
ravn0s
Brisbane, Queensland
9110 posts
he didnt leave sufficient space between the car and the tree.
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5061 posts
i sped yesterday. pretty fast! i didn't die though so i'm wondering what i did wrong. no xr6 perhaps. if every k over the limit is a killer i'm just wondering where all the bodies are at? :D
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3697 posts
he should have just left it barked
|
sparrow
Brisbane, Queensland
763 posts
yeah I've never had a problem with speeding
I realise that if I do have a problem with control of the car or someone else losing control of their car near me, there might be more chance of injury or death the faster I'm/they're going. but there's more chance of dying if I walk out my front door than not too. crossing the road is pretty dangerous compared to not crossing the road as well. in fact, just being alive increases the chance of death.
and that's why you should never live
This is an idiotic way to think - that's fine if you want to risk your life like that, but unlike your choice to cross the road, speeding is likely to kill people other than just yourself.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11052 posts
i sped yesterday. pretty fast! i didn't die though so i'm wondering what i did wrong. no xr6 perhaps. if every k over the limit is a killer i'm just wondering where all the bodies are at? :D
with that every k over is a killer thing - does it mean that every linear kilometre that you travel while continuously speeding, is a killer? or is it every kph over the speed limit that are the killers? if the former, does it reset if you stop speeding 1 cm short of a kilometre? and if the latter, does it scale linearly with every k over, or to some numeric power?
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11053 posts
This is an idiotic way to think - that's fine if you want to risk your life like that, but unlike your choice to cross the road, speeding is likely to kill people other than just yourself. is it really fine if I want to risk my life like that though? what about the impact it might have on my family, friends and business? and is my choice to cross the road really less likely to kill people other than myself? do more people cross the road in traffic than speed? even if not, wouldn't my crossing the road increase the chance of vehicles swerving into traffic or obstacles at speed in order to avoid me?
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2544 posts
Sarcasm detector broken!
What if when your crossing the road, there is a driver speeding, loses control of the car and then crashes into a tree killing everyone on board? Or what if you cross the road dangerously, ignoring all sense and drivers attempt to avoid you thereby hurting others? etc etc
Everything we do has repercussions. Every time someone goes over the speed limit (or anything really), they're doing a risk analysis, or a cost / benefit analysis. I enjoy going fast / I don't care what the law is. I need to get there faster / There aren't speed cameras here much.
|
Thundercracker
Brisbane, Queensland
2224 posts
If he was on LPG he wouldn't have been able to maintain such a high speed and it would have saved 5 lives WOULD SOMEONE THINK OF THE CHILDREN
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5062 posts
jim i think every linear kilometre that is travelled over the posted speed limit creates a new deranged human hell-bent on killing. (every k over = 1 killer). if you stop before the kilometre is fully travelled the killer is brought into being incomplete & disappears in a smelly cloud of false logic. however if too many incomplete killer clouds are too close they coalesce into a small dot. this is known as a demerit point.
speeding is likely to kill people other than just yourself.
well of course you would think this... you have already admitted you are 'slow' :D last edited by demon at 11:28:34 18/Jan/10
|
maxe
Brisbane, Queensland
14296 posts
yeh stock falcons aren't meant to be going fast
they're just not ready
couple jetpilot stickers and a magnaflow cat-back and he woulda made it
TUNING SAVES LIVES
|
HurricaneJim
Brisbane, Queensland
186 posts
The cure is to put speed limiters on all cars that have P plate drivers. Then put the car through a roadworthy inspection every three months for conformity. If the car fails or the driver (P plater) is caught speeding then mandatory minimum 12 month gaol sentence.
|
Red
Sydney, New South Wales
372 posts
yeh stock falcons aren't meant to be going fast
Modified Falcons don't go fast too well either.
glug glug glug

|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4016 posts
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5385 posts
I don't see why all new cars imported/made in Australia shouldn't have a 110km/hr speed limiter enforced on them
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9985 posts
For the rev-heads, maybe we could work out the difference in handling with extra people in the car.
Let's say we normally speed around with just our mate in the front seat. My and him weigh about 160kgs combined. I get to learn how the car handles with the two of us, taking bends at 60km/h etc etc.
Add at least 3 more bodies of men about the same weight, the weight in the car is now 400kgs (more than double before).
Obviously, that's a lot more weight than you're used to that you're going to have to deal with going around corners and having to stop. But for the car lovers/physicists, what proportion of the car's weight is that difference? That is, the added 240kgs of weight, how much is that in terms of the car's mass as a whole? If it was something like 10%, does that mean you should drive 10% slower than usual, or what?
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9986 posts
I don't see why all new cars imported/made in Australia shouldn't have a 110km/hr speed limiter enforced on them
80 for P platers.
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2492 posts
innocent my arse, you get into a xr6 with an underage drunk roof tiler who aspires to be a rap-star, that has a recent speeding conviction, with FIVE OTHER PEOPLE, at a party, and then you hang out the window while he speeds along yelling and screaming and carrying on and doing the finger to the drivers behind you, you deserve what you get.
They are young and stupid, at that age they think they're invincible, there was probably a bit of peer pressure involved bla bla bla I could keep going on.. They don't deserve it..
There is a difference between young 17 year old inexperienced kids driving to that of much older experienced drivers.. I don't mind thrashing the old 350 around here and there, but I do it when I know it's safe to. last edited by Martz at 12:12:33 18/Jan/10
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5387 posts
110 is a good place to start, if manufacturers would get on board with this so you had to take it to a dealer to get that figure adjusted ..
ie, you go in and buy your daughter a car, tell the dealer she's a p-plater and you want it speed limited to 80
no worries, he chucks a few codes in and voila, it's now a slow-mobile
when she gets off her P's you take it back and it's now capable of 100km/hr..
|
ravn0s
Brisbane, Queensland
9111 posts
would like to see how that 80 goes on the 100-110 highways.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5388 posts
it doesn't matter, P platers still have to do 80km/hr on the M1
ie, they have to (or should) sit in the left hand lane
They don't, but they're supposed to - this would just make sure they do
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9987 posts
Well I guess it'd take 12 minutes longer to drive to the gold coast, shock horror.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28982 posts
Young people are generally shit at risk assessment and evaluation. I remember some studies I found a while back about this but can't find them now.
The people in the OP are basically exact classic examples of all the things mentioned in this article
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6383 posts
130 teq, NT is 130 remember
also
poor falcon
|
Twinsen
Gold Coast, Queensland
467 posts
same make\model as mine and fuck its a heavy solid car so thats crazy to see it bent and twisted like that....
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2494 posts
Young people are generally shit at risk assessment and evaluation. I remember some studies I found a while back about this but can't find them now.
The people in the OP are basically exact classic examples of all the things mentioned in this article
yeah I thought it was funny how this cop pulled me over (for speeding like 75 in 60 zone) and started lecturing me about how speeding kills. I really wanted to say "hey dickhead, I'm 27, I've got 10 years of driving experience, I'm in an industrial area on a very wide and open road with no other traffic that I travel on everyday so I know the road like the back of my hand. I know how the vehicle handles, I know it's limits and I know mine.. So back the fuck off and shove your ticket up your arse and go off and target areas where accidents actually occur.."
but I didn't say that cause it wouldn't get me far :( I was actually very suprised he was there at all cause it was like 9pm in Pinkenba :/ last edited by Martz at 12:24:48 18/Jan/10
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9988 posts
Oh, so you didn't realise that all those things don't matter if someone else is at fault?
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3699 posts
They are young and stupid, at that age they think they're invincible, there was probably a bit of peer pressure involved bla bla bla I could keep going on.. They don't deserve it..
There is a difference between young 17 year old inexperienced kids driving to that of much older experienced drivers.. I don't mind thrashing the old 350 around here and there, but I do it when I know it's safe to.
Bullshit bullshit bullshit. I was 17 once too, and I wasn't a fucking bogan idiot. Even years before I got my licence I knew not to do something stupid like this. I never drove with passengers in the car, I never even told anybody I HAD a car, I parked the motherfucker 3 blocks away.
And no I don't "thrash the old 350" NOW either, whatever the fuck that means.
They don't deserve it? Oh well maybe every teenager should drive like idiots then, go for it!
A lot more shit drivers deserve to die, perhaps even you and your 350 (again, wtf).
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6039 posts
WTF, you can't have cars doing 80 on a highway, that would cause heaps of accidents.
Merging at 100 into 80 traffic. All the slow opens drivers having to get into the right lane to overtake, all the psycho open speeders will be doing even more zig zaggin and weaving to get between P platers going 80 in the left lane and open drivers doing 95-100 in the right.
That's just retarded :S
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5065 posts
everyone under the age of whatever age i am deserves to die, especially if thier nick starts with a t...FUCK! i h8 those dudes. or not.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5390 posts
the new GTR skyrine will engage/disengage the speed limiter depending where it is
if you drive on to a race track, the car goes into full race spec
we need shit like this
WTF, you can't have cars doing 80 on a highway, that would cause heaps of accidents.
that's the law as it is written today last edited by tequila at 12:42:02 18/Jan/10
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1709 posts
If any of you cunts vote to make P-platers have a max of 80km/h I am literally NEVER going to leave the right hand lane.
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5066 posts
the new GTR skyrine will engage/disengage the speed limiter depending where it is
if you drive on to a race track, the car goes into full race spec
we need shit like this
too easy to bypass for anyone with half a clue imo. a lot of bikes in europe are power-limited to 100ps... but everyone just replaces the cdi box with a non euro version & gets full power back.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11055 posts
WTF, you can't have cars doing 80 on a highway, that would cause heaps of accidents. lol
just lol
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28984 posts
Isn't there already some curfew law that if you're on your Ps, you're not allowed to have passengers after like 10pm or something?
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4018 posts
I never drove with passengers in the car, I never even told anybody I HAD a car, I parked the motherfucker 3 blocks away.
Wow.
I was one of very few that had their license for Year 12. I parked my car a few blocks away to stop my dickhead mates from trashing it (which happened in the school's parking lot), but everyone knew I had a car - and I gave everyone lifts everywhere for free cos I'm such a tops bloke.
Also, that 'every k over is a killer' must be a QLD thing because I've never heard that and you guys are talking like you've been brainwashed. I like the road safety campaign in TAS - the slogan is , "Just like that". It goes along the lines of 'you do something wrong, you're dead - just like that'
BillyHardball, putting on my physicist cap, I'm thinking the main issue is friction. If you have more in the car then if you get sideways you're going to have a much greater force in the lateral direction. Coefficient of static (non-sliding) friction is higher than coefficient of dynamic (sliding) friction - so once you've lost control you aren't going to get it back in a hurry, especially at speed. I'd be willing to bet that at 140km/h you're fucked with or without 5 others in the vehicle though.
@trog, there's a curfew law like that in VIC and I don't support it. I was always the driver until I was about 22yo and that curfew law would have changed my lifestyle significantly in a negative way. You can't deny that it infringes on responsible people. Why should they suffer because dickheads like to slam themselves into trees?
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6040 posts
lol
just lol How is that lol Jim?
You can't have cars driving on the same road but with different speed limits.
It might work on big 3-4+ lane highways, but 2 lanes... not a chance. I like to drive 100 in the left lane, so now I have to dodge a bunch of stupid P platers?
|
groganus
Brisbane, Queensland
905 posts
There is a difference between young 17 year old inexperienced kids driving to that of much older experienced drivers.. I don't mind thrashing the old 350 around here and there, but I do it when I know it's safe to.
At the end of the day the road is full of expeirenced and inexperienced drivers, it doesnt matter what you claim to be or what you actually are.. the only way the roads are safe is if everyone follows the rules...
sif youd listen to me anyway, i dont even drive.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28985 posts
It might work on big 3-4+ lane highways, but 2 lanes... not a chance. I like to drive 100 in the left lane, so now I have to dodge a bunch of stupid P platers? If only there was another lane that you could overtake them in
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1710 posts
Isn't there already some curfew law that if you're on your Ps, you're not allowed to have passengers after like 10pm or something?
Yeah there is, and it's really sensible IMO. I went to a driving skills course (NOT safe driving course) and they showed all the statistics and while there is little to none risk of just 1 passenger the risk goes up like crazy if you have someone in the back.
Combined with the increased risk of night time driving it's crazy not to follow it
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1711 posts
Actually i find having a car full of chicks heaps harder to control than my mates... they DON'T STOP TALKING :(
pregnancy this weddings that... I nearly had a heart attack
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5067 posts
Also, that 'every k over is a killer' must be a QLD thing because I've never heard that and you guys are talking like you've been brainwashed. I like the road safety campaign in TAS - the slogan is , "Just like that". It goes along the lines of 'you do something wrong, you're dead - just like that'
yeh i think the 'every k over is a killer' is a qld dot advert campain. we haven't been brainwashed... we simply find the overstatement of the facts amusing in it's fallacy. either way... it's just propaganda. it's not true that if you go a k over the limit you'll die. it's not true that if you do something 'wrong' you will die just like that (for every possible scenario of 'that'). why can't they keep it real & just say 'speeding increases the risk of accidents' or 'speeding increases the risk of damage during an accident'?
|
MoGs
Brisbane, Queensland
825 posts
Definitely a tragedy with a hint of stupidity mixed in. I can't believe the driver chose to drive irrationally even with his kid brother in the seat beside him. What a F**king idiot!!! I've at times sped abit too fast but only when i'm alone in the car.
Personally i think that compulsory advanced driving courses should be implemented, but although i'd like it to happen i know that it wont.
Such a waste of life from an imbecile driver...
|
Carson
Gippsland, Victoria
315 posts
and that's why you don't speed
Here, here.
P platers that go so far over the speed limit should get their car destroyed. While they watch. Then they can upload a vid of the driver watching the car being destroyed on youtube.
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6041 posts
If only there was another lane that you could overtake them in So I should just drive in the right lane then?
Then how do people overtake me?
They dont, they sit up my ass in there landcruiser bullbar flashing there stupid 4wd highbeams and now I have to slot back into the left land between 2 cars going 20km/hr under the speed limit.
Yeah that sounds very safe :S
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11056 posts
How is that lol Jim? os this is how it was when I had my P's in NSW and it worked fine
You can't have cars driving on the same road but with different speed limits.
It might work on big 3-4+ lane highways, but 2 lanes... not a chance. I like to drive 100 in the left lane, so now I have to dodge a bunch of stupid P platers?
why do you say you can't have cars on the same road but with different speed limits? you simply adhere to your speed limit and observe the keep left rules and that's it. simple
people already drive under the speed limit anyway, proving it's completely possible
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1712 posts
Personally i think that compulsory advanced driving courses should be implemented, but although i'd like it to happen i know that it wont.
govt says adv. driving courses make P platers overconfident.
Funny, isn't it? Going to a safe driving course makes you a dangerous driver.
|
Raven
Melbourne, Victoria
4062 posts
It seems to me that the people who rally for and write these stupid rule like P posters only bring to do 80 on otherwise 110km/h open roads are as brain-dead as they think the people they're trying to stop.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11057 posts
So I should just drive in the right lane then? no - why? you should overtake in the right lane and move back into the left lane.
wtf
Then how do people overtake me? they use the right lane after you've moved back into the left lane
They dont, they sit up my ass in there landcruiser bullbar flashing there stupid 4wd highbeams and now I have to slot back into the left land between 2 cars going 20km/hr under the speed limit.
Yeah that sounds very safe :S what you're describing is a combination of poor driving on either your part and/or theirs - not an issue with people driving slower than the speed limit:
- on your part because you're sitting in the right lane instead of moving into the left after overtaking
- on their part for not adhering to the rules themselves - tailgating/inappropriately using high beam/speeding
|
eightyeight
Brisbane, Queensland
1251 posts
wow you lot have no idea.
There is a time and place for everything. As an ex-owner of a ~500rwhp supra (which i owned for 6 years 1.5 of which it was turbo and bought when i was 18),I only once had a close call and that was at 60km/h. It got from 0-200km/h in such a short amount of time I really had to think about where and when I wanted to give it the beans. The only time I really got to have fun in it was on midnight mountain runs and on the highway late at night. I would never open it up on roads with intersecting street where some dickhead could pull out while I'm on boost.
On the highway though, if there were no cars around, no passengers in my car and my radar detector said the road was clear I would take it to the top of 5th and slow down within a mater of seconds. Dont ask how fast it got to i would rather not announce that on here.
I have to admit though I have also done 3 safety driving courses and I think they should be COMPULSORY when you get a licence.
Driving a car with a speed limiter to even 80km/h is just retarded because any old dickhead can get it to 80 then reef the wheel and put it into a tree.
Not all teenage drivers are shit, There are quite a few that i know who are actually really good drivers and I would trust their driving over older people I know.
|
fpot
Gold Coast, Queensland
16937 posts
Speed limiting cars to 80 is a dumb idea and anyone who instantly doesn't realise why is also dumb.
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5068 posts
88 so... your opinion is that it's ok to speed as long as there are no intersecting roads or it's midnight on a mountain. plus don't go 60 as it leads to close calls, never carry a passenger & make sure your radar detector tells you the road is clear. check!
i'm glad someone on this forum has an idea as no one else on this forum has an idea.
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2547 posts
Since moving up the coast, that has become more apparent. There are already people that are doing 80 on a 110 freeway. I just stick the cruise control on, and go around them. They dont, they sit up my ass in there landcruiser bullbar flashing there stupid 4wd highbeams and now I have to slot back into the left land between 2 cars going 20km/hr under the speed limit. If you're doing 105, and they're doing that, then they're going too fast. Ignore the fuckwit. Generally, you can see someone coming for miles, so you have plenty of time to get around the 80kph peoples. If not, the cockhead doing 160kph can fucking wait.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5391 posts
oh wise one, please explain it to us
they're not legally allowed to do 81km/hr, so why not pre-emptively enforce it?
if your argument is going to be that someone who isn't on their P's might drive it, then suck shit to that person
if the vehicle is registered to a P plater, that should be the cars top speed
if it saves 1 life it's worth some people getting their knickers in a not about being stuck doing 80 for a few minutes
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6042 posts
- on your part because you're sitting in the right lane instead of moving into the left after overtaking The left lane is 80km/hr, why would I move back into that lane?
If you're doing 105, and they're doing that, then they're going too fast. Ignore the fuckwit. Generally, you can see someone coming for miles, so you have plenty of time to get around the 80kph peoples. In light traffic yes.
Once there's a substantial amount of cars on the highway and all the P platers follow the law, the left lane will pretty much be permanently 80km/hr and it's not a matter of ducking around that 1 single granny. last edited by CHUB at 13:14:04 18/Jan/10
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6384 posts
'Every k over is a thriller' more like it
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5393 posts
but even as it stands right now there's always some wanker sitting in the right lane doing 100km/hr, it usually takes me a few horn beeps + high beams to get him to move but meh
P platers at the least of my concerns, they make up a small % of the driving population
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11058 posts
The left lane is 80km/hr, why would I move back into that lane?
no, it's not 80 - I think you're using some weird imaginary scenario where the left lane is just a constant stream of P-platers and you can't possibly do more than 80kph in that lane
but that's so far removed from reality, that you get a lol
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6385 posts
don't you mean an indicated 100kph teq
ie really 96 when i want to go a real 105
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6043 posts
but even as it stands right now there's always some wanker sitting in the right lane doing 100km/hr, it usually takes me a few horn beeps + high beams to get him to move but meh This is what I want to avoid.
The right lane should be for psychos like teq and Jim that like to intimidate people with there bullbars and go 105-110, leave the left lane for the other drivers that are happy to do 90-100. last edited by CHUB at 13:19:21 18/Jan/10
|
Dan
Special Text
Brisbane, Queensland
9933 posts
How would Marty have ever gotten the Delorean up to 88mph (141kmph) if he was speed limited to 110km. He wouldn't have and would have never saved his parents, would never have been born and it would be all your fault. Just think about that for a moment.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28986 posts
There is a time and place for everything. As an ex-owner of a ~500rwhp supra (which i owned for 6 years 1.5 of which it was turbo and bought when i was 18),I only once had a close call and that was at 60km/h. It got from 0-200km/h in such a short amount of time I really had to think about where and when I wanted to give it the beans. The only time I really got to have fun in it was on midnight mountain runs and on the highway late at night. I would never open it up on roads with intersecting street where some dickhead could pull out while I'm on boost. This is basically a strawman though. You're saying just because you had no accidents, noone else is likely to have accidents in fast cars?! It doesn't make sense and is contrary to almost all the evidence.
The time and place for driving 200km/h is on a private racecourse, really
I don't think speed limiting is that dumb an idea, though there are other things I would probably look at first. Of Qld's road fatalities in 2008, almost 30% of them were as a result of speeding. That sounds like a lot but really it was 'only' 88 people.
A quick Google indicates that another ~25% of fatalities were from "unrestrained vehicle occupants" (fucking what, people still don't wear seatbelts?) and another 25% from drunk driving.
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1713 posts
Just so you guys know, as a P plater, the one most dangerous thing that I do is get the shits when someone comes up my ass doing 20km/h above the speed limit. I panic, and have nearly hit the side railing twice on a curved road because when I try to get in the left hand lane I realise the cunt has already gone into that lane is accelerating again in my FUCKING BLIND SPOT so while I'm paying attention to that fuckwit I'm not focusing on the road ahead and my passenger is shitting herself as well and it's all a clutterfuck.
If I was forced to have people up my arse every 5 seconds I would crash the car in no time flat.
It's a stupid rule, and shouldn't be enforced.
|
eightyeight
Brisbane, Queensland
1252 posts
Fpot I'm not saying it's ok to speed but if you are going to do it don't do it somewhere stupid or somewhere where you can put other people's lives at risk.
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4020 posts
IMO it's a cultural thing. To 'go fast' is somehow cool. eightyeight, to me you are precisely the kind of chucklefuck that the Government points to when they say 'advanced driver safety courses make people over-confident' - you think you are a good driver, and suddenly it's ok for you to speed. You're wrong, and I hope that you're parents don't have to find that one out the hard way.
Australian roads are not suitable for speeding, no matter which way you look at them. Go for a drive on an Autobahn to see a road which suits driving fast - wide lanes and lots of them, wide fringes, banked turns and clean-as-a-whistle asphalt.
Edit: Replaced 'person' with 'chucklefuck'
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6044 posts
Just so you guys know, as a P plater, the one most dangerous thing that I do is get the shits when someone comes up my ass doing 20km/h above the speed limit. I panic, and have nearly hit the side railing twice on a curved road because when I try to get in the left hand lane I realise the cunt has already gone into that lane is accelerating again in my FUCKING BLIND SPOT so while I'm paying attention to that fuckwit I'm not focusing on the road ahead and my passenger is shitting herself as well and it's all a clutterfuck.
If I was forced to have people up my arse every 5 seconds I would crash the car in no time flat.
It's a stupid rule, and shouldn't be enforced. Awesome isn't it Phooks.
Now lets just make it so that happens once every 10 seconds and everyone will be much safer.
|
Nathan
Canberra, Australian Capital Territory
3318 posts
Speeding, particularly in urban areas, significantly increases the risk of injury to yourself or others while saving very little time.
Risk < Reward = dont take the risk
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2548 posts
Just think about that for a moment. Wow. Just wow. Dan is so deep it scares me. but even as it stands right now there's always some wanker sitting in the right lane doing 100km/hr, it usually takes me a few horn beeps + high beams to get him to move but meh j00 can wait till I get around my 80kph P plater! Your hirux ain't so scary.
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1714 posts
You're wrong, and I hope that you're parents don't have to find that one out the hard way.
Actually his whole family think he is the safest driver in the world.
Which is LAME because i am totally the safest! ;)
|
fpot
Gold Coast, Queensland
16938 posts
I never said anything about you speeding that was demon.
It's because a 20km/h disparity among cars on a highway is unsafe. If everyone is traveling the same speed it reduces the chances and severity of accidents. Plus it's just the praticality of speed limiting P platers cars and enforcing it.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11059 posts
I don't intentionally intimidate anyone with my bullbar
in fact when driving my patrol on bitumen I drive it like an old granny cos it's heavy, high, sways like a hammock and has barely adequate brakes. to give you an idea, I was able to drive from hillcrest out near browns plains, to our old office at taringa and only need to use the brakes to slow down, a total of 5 times in normal traffic. I drove it so conservatively that gears and inclines were enough to come to a standstill all other times in that 30 minute trip
phooks, you sound really shit at driving a car - I think you highlight one of the biggest flaws in our licensing system: it's too easy for unco cunts to get and hold a driver's license
|
nF
Forum Hero
Wynnum, Queensland
16203 posts
I panic, and have nearly hit the side railing twice on a curved road because when I try to get in the left hand lane I realise the cunt has already gone into that lane is accelerating again in my FUCKING BLIND SPOT so while I'm paying attention to that fuckwit I'm not focusing on the road ahead and my passenger is shitting herself as well and it's all a clutterfuck.
And this is why you shouldn't be driving.
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1715 posts
Jim for your next drive just limit yourself to 80km.h and come back to QGL and tell us the huge success and how much more safe you feel, k?
|
maxe
Brisbane, Queensland
14297 posts
Speed limiters are fucking retarded
Anything that gives a driver less control over a car is a hazard
Speed limiter at 180, yeah fine
Speed limiter at fucking 110? Are you fucking kidding?
people crash cars, thats life
|
eightyeight
Brisbane, Queensland
1253 posts
No trog even though I haven't crashed its becausw I understand the physics of how a car handles and I know my limits. Alot of people do not and I would not recommes doing a mountain run in a powerful car unless you know the car well and the road very well. Some people can just naturally drive better than others too
|
Dazhel
Gold Coast, Queensland
694 posts
Also, that 'every k over is a killer' must be a QLD thing
It is, this and a lot of other advertising catch phrases are abysmal. I don't envy the job of a catch phrase writer though as there must be only so many ways you can say "Use your common sense, fool".
Mostly unrelated: following on from Tourism Australia's "Where the Bloody Hell are ya?!" debacle, QLD is apparently launching a campaign with the catch phrase "So what are you up for?", presumably designed to draw tourists from overseas into the seedy Fortitude Valley back streets.
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2496 posts
the only problem i see with cars doing 80 is when entering a highway.. you really should be entering highway traffic at the same speed as what they are doing... eg speed up to 100km/h when entering a 100km/h highway.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5394 posts
yeah any kind of PANIC while driving = fail
you should remain calm at all times, even when sideways at 140km/hr about to die in a fireball of twisted molten metal
I use my bullbar as an intimidation device against some people, it's not so effective on the highway though because any kind of love tap at 100+km/hr isn't going to end well for anyoen involved
at low speeds though, a love tap from the bullbar is enough to send most motorists cowering back to their own fucking lane
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1716 posts
And this is why you shouldn't be driving.
FYI I am aware that is dangerous for me to do. Which is why I posted it. I'm improving in that area as I drive.
It's called being 'inexperienced' and i have the common sense to know that I am.
So how about you stfu :)
|
RockitMan
Brisbane, Queensland
5480 posts
P platers should be limited to 4 cylinders (and not the sporty ones).
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2549 posts
phooks, you sound really shit at driving a car - I think you highlight one of the biggest flaws in our licensing system: it's too easy for unco cunts to get and hold a driver's license He's not going to be unco forever though (one would hope). It's just experience. Imagine him hitting a railing at 110 compared to 80 :D
We seem to be forgetting that in that scenario, the fuckwit sitting up his arse and weaving through traffic is the one breaking the rules, not Phooks.
|
eightyeight
Brisbane, Queensland
1254 posts
Phooks pick me up sometime il teach you how to drve ;-)
|
ravn0s
Brisbane, Queensland
9113 posts
teq sounds like the kinda person that shouldnt be driving.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5395 posts
it's both of them actually, if you endanger anyone else while driving, no matter if someone else caused you to do it directly or indirectly, you must admit some fault
unless you were pushed into that situation, if you just panic and cause that accident though, it's completely your own fault
It should be a lot more difficult to get your license though, and there should be no "auto" license
if you can't drive stick, you can't drive for shit
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2550 posts
at low speeds though, a love tap from the bullbar is enough to send most motorists cowering back to their own fucking lane Please tell me you're joking.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11060 posts
Jim for your next drive just limit yourself to 80km.h and come back to QGL and tell us the huge success and how much more safe you feel, k? my next drive will be from office to home, it's 50 and 60 zones only
also, here's a list of licenses and restrictions imposed on them, including lower-than-signed speed limits:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Driver%27s_licence_in_Australia
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6045 posts
It should be a lot more difficult to get your license though, and there should be no "auto" license
if you can't drive stick, you can't drive for shit I agree completely.
Doesn't matter if you're buying an auto straight off, if you don't have the time, energy or skill to get a manual license you don't deserve to be on the road.
at low speeds though, a love tap from the bullbar is enough to send most motorists cowering back to their own fucking lane I just assumed he is joking... because doing stuff like that will get you killed pretty quickly. last edited by CHUB at 13:39:03 18/Jan/10
|
Twinsen
Gold Coast, Queensland
468 posts
Let's blame this on Fast and the Furious and censorship all movies!!!!!
Not to mention the computer games!!!!
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5396 posts
Please tell me you're joking.
if it comes down to (and it has on more than one occasion) me pushing you back into your own lane vs. me mounting a gutter to avoid an accident with you
I'm going to push you back into your own lane because at least in that scenario you're at fault and you have to pay to fix my car
if I mount the gutter and do some damage, it's my own fault
I take the cheapest option to fix
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3700 posts
there should be no "auto" license
if you can't drive stick, you can't drive for shit
Yeah well I reckon everyone should have to learn to drive a steam engine and be able to shovel coal into a furnace while they drive!
You're from the past dude.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28987 posts
No trog even though I haven't crashed its becausw I understand the physics of how a car handles and I know my limits. Alot of people do not and I would not recommes doing a mountain run in a powerful car unless you know the car well and the road very well. Some people can just naturally drive better than others too yeh but I bet that's exactly what the dude from the OP was thinking, until he slid into a tree sideways at 150km/h
The point is, people - ESPECIALLY young people - are terribly bad at self-rating themselves when it comes to things like driving skills. Note I'm not saying you're terrible - for all I know you could be the greatest driver ever... but most people are not, and think they are
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6046 posts
I'm going to push you back into your own lane because at least in that scenario you're at fault and you have to pay to fix my car Now you REALLY have to be joking.
You're completely at fault hitting someone from behind.
Yeah well I reckon everyone should have to learn to drive a steam engine and be able to shovel coal into a furnace while they drive!
You're from the past dude. Do you have an auto license thermite? last edited by CHUB at 13:44:14 18/Jan/10
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2551 posts
if it comes down to (and it has on more than one occasion) me pushing you back into your own lane vs. me mounting a gutter to avoid an accident with you
I'm going to push you back into your own lane because at least in that scenario you're at fault and you have to pay to fix my car
if I mount the gutter and do some damage, it's my own fault How would I be at fault if your running into the back of people pushing them wherever you think they belong?!
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1717 posts
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2497 posts
my next drive will be from office to home, it's 50 and 60 zones only
I think he's talking about doing 80 when everyone else is doing 100..
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5398 posts
how am I pushing into the back of someone?
I mean for example, if I'm travelling down a 2 lane road with some bends in it and the silly bitch next to me can't navigate the bend without entering my lane, I'm more likely to just ram the bitch out of the way than I am going to mount the gutter / potentially damage my car
I don't just go up behind people and nudge them because I can heh
|
scuzzy
Brisbane, Queensland
13746 posts
Twinsen
Gold Coast, Queensland
469 posts
I hate those fucks who merge onto the hiway and are going well below the speed limit, even though there is a dotted line at the end of the merge lane meaning they need to give way, they bloody pull out anyway resulting on you slowing down to let them in going to slow...
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6047 posts
I mean for example, if I'm travelling down a 2 lane road with some bends in it and the silly bitch next to me can't navigate the bend without entering my lane, I'm more likely to just ram the bitch out of the way than I am going to mount the gutter / potentially damage my car That doesn't happen very often.
I don't just go up behind people and nudge them because I can heh That's EXACTLY what it sounded like considering the past several pages has purely been on people with bullbars intimidating people in the right lane. last edited by CHUB at 13:50:23 18/Jan/10
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2498 posts
haha I remember when I was in my ute in bumper to bumper traffic.. we were all standing still and this really impatient chick kept on nudging slowly forward behind thinking she's getting somewhere and she kept on nudging forward and hit my tow bar, she obviously didn't know it was there and her face was priceless.. a little bit of paint on my tow bar vs her now cracked bumper bar..
|
fpot
Gold Coast, Queensland
16939 posts
teq has a habit of posting things, being called out on it, and then hurriedly changing his story when he has realised what happened. He did it about 4 times in the google censors australia thread.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11061 posts
I don't have an auto-restricted license, they didn't even exist when I got mine
I have an auto and a manual
I have predominantly driven manuals over the 20+ years I've held a license
I agree with thermite
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6048 posts
I bet thermites one of the tards that has an auto license though.
You're an odd one out Jim, it's usually only the handicaps that believe auto licenses are good.
|
eightyeight
Brisbane, Queensland
1255 posts
WTF thermite there are a fuckload of manual cars still being made how is a manual licence a thing of the past?
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5399 posts
nah people like my brother who just got auto licenses and never learned anything more than brake + accelerate + basic steering
they're the ones who shouldn't be driving, absolutely do not care about their car/etc, just use it to get from A-B and wouldn't know how to inflate a tyre etc
if you're driving something that can kill, you should know a lot more about it than how to start it and move it
fpot has a habbit of being a wanker
I can see how you might have made the connection to me ramming people in the bum, because I didn't say "at lower speeds and not on the highway", but who does lower speeds on the highway?
It has happened to me where I've had to push someone out of the way to avoid having an accident myself, it was a cab driver
probably one of hardwares mates
in the end he had to pay to fix both of our cars and I paid $0
if I had of swerved to avoid the accident, mounted a gutter and bent a rim/suspension etc, it would have been 100% my fault and would have cost me significant coin
fuck that
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3450 posts
No one's mentioned here but one of the most effective things drivers should be made to is a defensive driving course
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11062 posts
You're an odd one out Jim, it's usually only the handicaps that believe auto licenses are good.
I've never researched it, I just don't see the correlation between being able to manipulate a clutch/accelerator/stick and competently drive a vehicle - in fact, particularly in more and more modern vehicles, it may be riskier to be driving a manual.
there are a heap of unco people who have manual licences and drive manuals - they learn through repetition and simply robot the process with no understanding whatsoever of how a clutch works, how engine braking works or the correlation between them all. in a sticky situation they might even be more likely to fuck up and make things worse when driving a manual than an auto
|
paveway
Brisbane, Queensland
11338 posts
infi
Brisbane, Queensland
14909 posts
when will young fellas learn to drive sensibly. i am all for cracking down down even harder on drivers under 25.
basically they should never be in a position to kill passengers for starters, and should only be allowed to drive during daylight. kids (anyone under 25) do not have spacial capacity and maturity to drive safely.
this needless loss of life is just horrible.
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3701 posts
There is no such thing as an "auto licence", my license is exactly the same as anybody else's. No I've never driven a manual, had access to one, or see any reason that the added burden of using old technology makes you better at driving, if anything it's just another distraction for you. Manual transmission, and the idea of gears in general, is a limitation of the technology, not an added benefit.
The purpose of a car, and the only reason you should ever drive one, is to get from point A to point B. If you disagree you are instantly a bogan. Cars are not something to be enjoyed.
last edited by thermite at 14:07:50 18/Jan/10
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4021 posts
Note I'm not saying you're terrible - for all I know you could be the greatest driver ever.
Hahaha. I'm not such a fence-sitter. I'll go on the record as saying that you're a shit driver, eightyeight - based on the as yet unpublished high level of correlation between people that think they are good drivers vs. # of accidents.
Phooks, eightyeight will stop by and pick you up along with three of your best mates and you can all go and find a suitable oak tree together.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5400 posts
it's the sheer fact that they can get their license very easily, drive for years very easily and never have a need to work out what engine braking is and so on
the kinds of people who get auto licenses only are the kinds of people who should be scrutinized more imo
they don't think of driving as something that is particularly important/difficult to do, so they don't put in the effort required to maintain safety
|
fpot
Gold Coast, Queensland
16940 posts
A summary of teq's thoughts -
hurrr P platers should be limited to 80
hurrrrrr if you can't drive a manual you shouldn't be allowed to drive. I base this statement of nothing.
hurrrrrrrrrrrrr thing in way I hit with bullbar. Me teq.
More amazing insights coming soon.
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6049 posts
There is no such thing as an "auto licence", my license is exactly the same as anybody else's. No I've never driven a manual, had access to one, or see any reason that the added burden of using old technology makes you better at driving, if anything it's just another distraction for you. Manual transmission, and the idea of gears in general, is a limitation of the technology, not an added benefit. That about sums it up.
Auto license for retards.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11063 posts
yeh I thought he summed it up pretty well - generally speaking, I reckon it was accurate
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3451 posts
basically they should never be in a position to kill passengers for starters, and should only be allowed to drive during daylight. kids (anyone under 25) do not have spacial capacity and maturity to drive safely.
That would hurt the economy surely you can't be suggesting it?
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1718 posts
 qgl driving threads ftw
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3702 posts
Maybe there is such a thing as an automatic license ( link), but they don't seem to make a habit of giving those out.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5401 posts
ok the fact that they drive the auto vs. the manual might not make them any worse, perhaps it's just that the kind of people who tend to get auto-only licenses tend to be less interested in cars, less interested in knowing the inner workings, less interested in general ...
fair assumption?
|
maxe
Brisbane, Queensland
14298 posts
I would prefer drivers that were interested in not crashing compared to one that was interested in how their engine works
|
CHUB
Brisbane, Queensland
6050 posts
perhaps it's just that the kind of people who tend to get auto-only licenses tend to be less interested in cars, less interested in knowing the inner workings, less interested in general ...
fair assumption? It's not the fact that they're driving auto's that bothers me.
It's exactly what you said, I don't believe they have the right attitude to be a lifelong safe driver.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5402 posts
I will avoid a crash if I can, so long as it's in my best interests financially speaking.
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3703 posts
I appreciate physics and that I think is a big advantage, helps me not go 150 kmph sideways or stick fragile glass jars up my arse.
|
Raven
Melbourne, Victoria
4063 posts
1. Anyone who calls it "engine" braking is a poser who doesn't truly understand it. It's *compression* braking, not 'engine' braking.
2. I'd love to see the stats on P-plater deaths in Manuals vs Automatics. If I had to hazard a guess, the majority will be manuals. I'm not inferring at all that manuals are harder to drive or cause more crashes, but I will throw out the hypothesis that hoon mentality types tend towards driving manuals over automatics.
FYI, I have a manual license, but I bought an auto.
3. This morning it absolutely pissed down with rain on the drive to work. I've rarely seen anything like it. 80km/h 3 lane stretches of Ferntree Gully Road were reduced to 50km/h being the most anyone would do, which is fine, visiblity was SFA. But dickheads still wanted to sit right up peoples asses.
4. I disagree that auto drivers can't drive - MSG mahal drivers I watch are still wiping off their speed as they go through corners. It's all fine if you're just keeping your speed constant and under control, but most dickheads don't realise that a reduction of speed increases inertia. Auto drivers don't generally have to worry about this do mch, because even if they braked too late and didn't downshift early enough, they don't then have to attempt to downshift right on or (gasp) through the corner.
|
Twinsen
Gold Coast, Queensland
470 posts
I have an auto license it was no easier, had to do the same test to get my lisense as others, I have a keen interest in cars drive a decent one and know all about its inner workings, Engine breaking? mine does it automatically.
if anything its one less distraction to handle while driving - yes you get a better feel for the car itself and yes it probably means that allot more pricks txt\on phone while driving an auto cause not have to worry about the gears...
The way the engine works doesn't mean shit its the dick behind the wheel which makes the differance...
|
Thundercracker
Brisbane, Queensland
2225 posts
I doubt there is much correlation between auto license holders and their chance of crashing. You will probably find factors such as experience and soberness to carry weight. Lots of drivers don't have much of a clue, but what makes them dangerous is when they either aren't paying attention or when they don't understand the boundaries of safe driving. There are plenty of bad drivers that drive slow and rarely have accidents. I'm sure lots of noobs think they are in control up to the point where the car goes sideways.
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3452 posts
ok the fact that they drive the auto vs. the manual might not make them any worse, perhaps it's just that the kind of people who tend to get auto-only licenses tend to be less interested in cars, less interested in knowing the inner workings, less interested in general ...
fair assumption?
How about this people with manual licenses are more interested in their cars, people who are more interested in their cars have better cars, people with better cars have something to prove through their car, people with something to prove about their car will drive more recklessly to prove it, people who drive recklessly are more reckless generally ... therefore they beat their wives
fair assumption?
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5403 posts
I have an auto license it was no easier, had to do the same test to get my lisense as others, I have a keen interest in cars drive a decent one and know all about its inner workings, Engine breaking? mine does it automatically.
point-in-case. your auto doesn't engine brake at all
also, it was much easier to get your license because you didn't have to think about too much at the one time (balancing clutch while reversing and checking mirrors to do a reverse parallel park?)
engine braking and compressing braking are the same thing, you're just a nitpicking fag
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3453 posts
also, it was much easier to get your license because you didn't have to think about too much at the one time (balancing clutch while reversing and checking mirrors to do a reverse parallel park?)
So they can focus more on driving safely....
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5404 posts
yeah.. or, they failed their manual test because they're incapable of concentrating on more than one thing at any given time
Riddle me this, if you can avoid a crash with another car but it means that you yourself will have to potentially damage your vehicle, what would you do?
run up the gutter or run into the other car?
one way costs you money, the other doesn't.
|
infi
Brisbane, Queensland
14911 posts
That would hurt the economy surely you can't be suggesting it?
I can't comprehend how youths dying needlessly can possibly be good for the economy. Scientists should do a study on you.
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4023 posts
Riddle me this, if you can avoid a crash with another car but it means that you yourself will have to potentially damage your vehicle, what would you do?
It's split-minute decision. You can't decide in a forum how you will react. When I had my bad crash I t-boned the chick in the other vehicle and the only thing that I actively did was make a small steering correction to hit her as straight-on as I could and then take my hands off the steering wheel so I didn't break my wrists.
Hurts my chest just thinking about it.
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3455 posts
You're meant to be a libertarian you can't follow your own mantra very well can you.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5405 posts
well I must be awesome because I have the reaction time of a steel trap
when the taxi tried to push me off the road everything slowed down matrix-styles, I made the decision based purely on financial information available to me at the time
gutter = expensive, taxi = cheap
but then again, I'm pretty fucking awesome
hey fpot
|
Scooter
Brisbane, Queensland
2363 posts
I think the other car is running into you, if I understand the scenario as you tried to explain it before.
There's a huge difference.
|
Thundercracker
Brisbane, Queensland
2226 posts
If someone swerved into me I wouldn't avoid them if that meant climbing a gutter, hitting pedestrians or swerving into another lane where I would be at fault for hitting a car. But as pinky said, easy to say on the intarwebs, entirely different in practice.
Hurts my chest just thinking about it.
Getting punched in the nose by an airbag also cains. Probably better than the alternative tho.
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2499 posts
I don't get all this bs you guys are on about, my mum has NFI about cars, she drives a MANUAL and NEVER had an accident.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11064 posts
1. Anyone who calls it "engine" braking is a poser who doesn't truly understand it. It's *compression* braking, not 'engine' braking. and this compression occurs where? in the engine, which is far more likely why it's called engine braking than to be 'a poser'.
lol
I saw someone mention that auto's don't engine brake but my auto downshifts by itself all the time as it detects different things such as downhills, braking etc. not sure how common that is tho
incidentally, in spite of this it doesn't really do engine breaking cos it's a diesel
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6386 posts
Mr Hardware's unproven opinion:
1. Manuals are sucky, old technology that can be and are beaten by autos. The new 5+ speed autos are often faster and more fuel efficient than a dirty, old tech manual.
2. I don't hold anything against anyone who has an auto-only licence. You don't go from being car noob to car master just because you have to do something that should be done for you, ie shift gears.
3. I had a manual car for years, and when i went to hire that getz for the great ocean road, i remembered how much fun a manual was...for the first 40mins. For next 5 hours i cursed this extra effort i had to undertake that i had to be using, and that i couldn't hold my wife's hand/leg whilst driving.
I don't get all this bs you guys are on about, my mum has NFI about cars, she drives a AUTOMATIC and NEVER had an accident.
last edited by hardware at 14:45:05 18/Jan/10
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
390 posts
No one's mentioned here but one of the most effective things drivers should be made to is a defensive driving course
i disagree. memory retention of a two-day course is very low, and it just gives the driver the illusion that they know what they are doing.
|
infi
Brisbane, Queensland
14913 posts
You're meant to be a libertarian you can't follow your own mantra very well can you.
yeah, allowing people to kill themselves and their friends and family. sounds like awesome policy, you dunce.
|
Thundercracker
Brisbane, Queensland
2227 posts
two hands on the wheel buddy!
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5406 posts
thats for you bimmer drivers only (and probably audis etc, other non-cheap-skate autos)
my brothers magna, when it down shifts, will actually fling you forward if you're doing it too rapidly / too high revs
I like how they make indicators an option on BMWs but it will engine brake for you, that's classy ;)
last edited by tequila at 14:46:58 18/Jan/10
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6387 posts
two hands on the wheel buddy! fuck that. i drive one handed, hell i can even drift one handed. with power steer and a big man palm you don't need two hands. if i have my mrs in the car one hand is on her, the other is on the wheel, if it's just me i use the other hand for the wheel and one arm on the window, cool cunt style. last edited by hardware at 14:47:36 18/Jan/10
|
Spook
Brisbane, Queensland
27725 posts
just signing in to say that autos are fine for women and spastics
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6388 posts
wasn't your skyrine 4-door an auto spook?
last edited by hardware at 14:50:02 18/Jan/10
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3457 posts
i disagree. memory retention of a two-day course is very low, and it just gives the driver the illusion that they know what they are doing.
Insurance companies have lowered premiums for those who take these courses (they don't do this unless it's warranted) and a quick google shows they have been linked to reduced accident rates.
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5069 posts
if it's just me i use the other hand for the wheel and one arm on the window, cool cunt style.
hahah i see so many knobs doing this & it really doesn't look cool :P it looks like the car is being driven by a stroke victim with a paralysed right arm :]
(edit) actually... i'm talking about the dudes that hang their arm out the windows... not on the window sill. last edited by demon at 14:57:57 18/Jan/10
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5407 posts
I drive with my right arm on the window but it's my steering arm too, my left arm usually just sits on my left thigh waiting to do something
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
391 posts
i disagree. memory retention of a two-day course is very low, and it just gives the driver the illusion that they know what they are doing. Insurance companies have lowered premiums for those who take these courses (they don't do this unless it's warranted) and a quick google shows they have been linked to reduced accident rates.
that doesn't disprove what i said.
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2500 posts
I don't get all this bs you guys are on about, my mum has NFI about cars, she drives a AUTOMATIC and NEVER had an accident.
nope, pretty sure it's a manual.
Also compression braking is something to with the exhaust slowing down the vehicle which is in trucks...
(edit) actually... i'm talking about the dudes that hang their arm out the windows... not on the window sill.
and what's wrong with that? last edited by Martz at 15:01:36 18/Jan/10
|
nF
Forum Hero
Wynnum, Queensland
16204 posts
1. Anyone who calls it "engine" braking is a poser who doesn't truly understand it. It's *compression* braking, not 'engine' braking.
^ said by a poser who truly doesn't understand it. Compression braking is jake braking which cars can't do, engine braking is what cars do.
They are similar concepts, but polar opposites. Engine braking uses vacuum generated by the throttle being closed to create a drag on the engine and therefore the drive train. Diesels do not have a throttle, so they work in reverse by actually compressing the air that is freely entering the engine. The compression creates the drag.
So, engine braking in a car is not compression braking. Also, lol.
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3704 posts
what like reverse thrusters
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28989 posts
that doesn't disprove what i said. But the only thing that really matters here is relevance from an overall statistical sense, surely.
If insurance companies reckon it's going to save them money by having done a defensive driving course, then that's a pretty good indicator that, in general, it's probably safer to have done it.
That said I'm sure someone has told me there's a study somewhere that shows people that do those driving courses are more prone to have accidents, for exactly the reason you described :) but I can't find it now
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1855 posts
just signing in to say that autos are fine for women and spastics
Huh, yep.
Most auto-drivers are perfectly ok drivers, probably just didnt figured they would only ever drive auto's so got an auto licence, doesnt make sense to me but whatever.
There are certain auto-only drivers that have no fucken clue, could only comprehend go-stop-steer. Thoses are the auto drivers that are bad.
They probably arent to go get into an accident like the one posted, but they probbably are going to piss off alot of people by doing things like staying in the right lane doing 90, merge on people etc. These are the people when you drive past them after they have done something dumb and they look at you like "what have I done?"
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2552 posts
I hate those fucks who merge onto the hiway and are going well below the speed limit, even though there is a dotted line at the end of the merge lane meaning they need to give way, they bloody pull out anyway resulting on you slowing down to let them in going to slow... The way I was taught in NSW was to give way to merging traffic. That makes complete sense to me. From the QLD Transport site... In most cases this enables a driver to find a safe gap in the traffic and then change lanes into it. It is also common practice, and recommended by Queensland Transport, that drivers already on the freeway exercise courtesy and allow space for drivers trying to enter the freeway, either by adjusting their speed or changing lanes. Having said all that, I completely agree with you. Native QLDers just can't merge... Get a fucking wriggle on people!! The laws governing construction of roads in QLD are more lenient too, so you get these 50m slip roads where you're expected to go from 30kph to 100kph in 50m.
The people that really shit me though are the ones that fucking stop at the dotted line.. ARGH!! Here I am, putting my foot down off my 50m slip road, look over my shoulder to find a gap, turn back around, and there's this fucking idiot lawn bowler completely stationary while I accelerate towards them at 100kph. last edited by Mantra at 15:12:52 18/Jan/10
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28990 posts
Most auto-drivers are perfectly ok drivers, probably just didnt figured they would only ever drive auto's so got an auto licence, doesnt make sense to me but whatever. This is a pointless generalisation though
unless you can come to me and say "here are the statistics clearly showing auto drivers are more likely to be in an accident than manual drivers", it's utterly meaningless
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5408 posts
thats only a problem if you don't have a turbo
|
infi
Brisbane, Queensland
14915 posts
i drove manual for over 10 years, and would never go back. manual are for chumps.
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2553 posts
thats only a problem if you don't have a turbo I do have a turbo? :D I also have two clutches, engine braking and triptronic transmission that makes me happy in my pants.
Auto drivers are probably fine. It's more about the person driving the car than the way you change gears. I also have a Subaru Forester that's a manual, and it shits me having to change gears. Especially in traffic. 1-2-3-2-stop 1-2-stop 1-stop etc etc... bah!
/me waves walking stick
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5409 posts
so why are you complaining about the tiny merge distances? :)
maybe you just need moar boost
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1856 posts
But trog, even in the bit I quoted, I said that most auto drivers are perfectly ok drivers?
I was saying from experience I've seen the auto-only drivers that got an auto-only licence becuase thats all they can comprehend, they can only just manage stop-go, steer and look straight ahead. Anything above that like being aware of other cars around them, understanding how a car handles under an emergency situation, stuff like that they just dont get.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28991 posts
I was saying from experience I've seen the auto-only drivers that got an auto-only licence becuase thats all they can comprehend, they can only just manage stop-go, steer and look straight ahead. Anything above that like being aware of other cars around them, understanding how a car handles under an emergency situation, stuff like that they just dont get. How are you figuring out that the people are doing that are driving automatics?
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4027 posts
On the merge issue they are fucking hopeless in Tassie too I've noticed. They simply will not let you in.
They are pretty good in VIC - I think the extra traffic volume means leniency is pretty much a requirement to be a driver. I have had the odd dickwad not let me merge though.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5410 posts
its not because they are driving an auto either, it's because they are more likely to be the kind of person who doesn't take driving as seriously as it should be taken
the kinds of people who are "stop-goers", ie they can stop and go but not much else .. are more likely to get an auto license
these people are problematic and nearly all of them will wind up with an auto-only license because its the only way they will pass the test
so its not the fault of the transmission but the majority of them end up lumped in an auto car because they're just too useless
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2555 posts
so why are you complaining about the tiny merge distances? :) Well, it's definitely a problem in the Forester... and for most people, so you're always backing off while the slower cars get their second wind.
Does anyone remember the older cars from the late 60s that had "automatic" as part of the badge? They advertised it because it was a good thing! :)
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1857 posts
And there are manual drivers like that too, except they managed to learn a manual, but do it realy badly, change gears way too soon, dont change down quick enough, go around corners in 3rd etc. They probably should have gotten an auto only licence cause they just dont get driving a manual.
I agree that that it doesnt make any difference if you have an auto-only licence, I just dont think we should have it to weed out those bad auto-only drivers that I mentioned. Unless your a complete spastic, it wont make a difference.
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4028 posts
tequila and hardware are in a car together and no music is playing - who's driving?
The police.
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1858 posts
How are you figuring out that the people are doing that are driving automatics?
I've been in cars with them.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
28992 posts
yeh I wouldn't mind getting rid of the auto-only license.. I say that as someone that has an auto-only one. I got one cuz we only had auto cars and I was miles away from getting my own car and it was just easier to learn on my parents cars than spend jillions on lessons.
I can drive a manual car fine though - drove one regularly to work, sometimes naughtily without a license, a time I look back on with incredible amazement at how fucking stupid it was to do that - and during the time I drove it I sure learned to hate the fuck out of manual cars
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3458 posts
the kinds of people who are "stop-goers", ie they can stop and go but not much else .. are more likely to get an auto license
these people are problematic and nearly all of them will wind up with an auto-only license because its the only way they will pass the test
The kind of people who get manuals are hoon v8 drivers
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2556 posts
I thought this was interesting...
|
Crunch
Perth, Western Australia
1029 posts
I've been in cars with them.
So that would be a sample size of what, 5? 10? Oh just hangon on a second the phone is rining - oh look it's AC Nielson wanting your data for some research they're conducting.
Also, triptronic transmissions. that's hardly high tech, is it?
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1859 posts
and during the time I drove it I sure learned to hate the fuck out of manual cars
Manuals are a fucken pain in the ass in suburban areas, if I was doing a commute like you do every day, i'd probably end up getting an auto.
But on my commute to work, through canungra and over tamborine mountain, a manual rules, its 100k most of the way except over the mountain with windy roads, having a manual is heaps better.
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6389 posts
i'm pretty sure that driving retards will be driving retard regardless of transmission, so the 'everyone should get a manual licence' is a moot point.
nope, pretty sure it's a manual.
Nah i'm talking about my mum.
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2558 posts
Also, triptronic transmissions. that's hardly high tech, is it? This is me not biting to such an obvious troll :P
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2501 posts
manuals are good for people who are looking to save an average of $2k when purchasing a car and for sports/turbo cars..
Otherwise auto's all the way, manual is too much effort for daily commuting, especially in bumper to bumper traffic during peak periods.
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1860 posts
i'm pretty sure that driving retards will be driving retard regardless of transmission
Probably true.
|
eightyeight
Brisbane, Queensland
510 posts
This post has been removed.
Reason: Inapprop. language/links
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6155 posts
I can't believe no one has mentioned that Pinky managed to create a thread that received more than 2 replies!
I've wanted to reply to this thread all day and couldn't log in arrgggghhh so many stupid comments it's a field day.
Just worked out it was my new work PC (that I got late Friday) not allowing cookies or some shit, but now the moments are lost, lost forever :(
last edited by mission at 16:40:05 18/Jan/10
|
Spook
Brisbane, Queensland
27726 posts
wasn't your skyrine 4-door an auto spook?
nah, woudlnt have bought it if it was an auto
|
infi
Brisbane, Queensland
14918 posts
don't worry mission, i'm sure it would have been gold.
|
sparrow
Brisbane, Queensland
766 posts
I can't believe no one has mentioned that Pinky managed to create a thread that received more than 2 replies!
I've wanted to reply to this thread all day and couldn't log in arrgggghhh so many stupid comments it's a field day.
Just worked out it was my new work PC (that I got late Friday) not allowing cookies or some shit, but now the moments are lost, lost forever :(last edited by mission at 16:40:05 18/Jan/10
Looking at the rest of the thread, I really don't think you've missed out on much.
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6156 posts
Just the dissin' sparrow, just the dissin'.
Infi knows the score.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5411 posts
the only time I was ever in the back of a police car, I wasn't handcuffed
hence, I'm awesome
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2562 posts
the only time I was ever in the back of a police car, I wasn't handcuffed
hence, I'm awesome Was that to assist in the cupping of the balls so you didn't get put in jail? QLD Police are always striving for quality in all aspects of their role.
:D
|
d[o_0]b
Brisbane, Queensland
3505 posts
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5412 posts
it was so i could use my hands to accurately describe how I killed all of the ninjas while protecting myself from immediate danger
|
Mantra
Crusty old man
Brisbane, Queensland
2563 posts
 ahahhah!
|
Superform
Netherlands
6003 posts
would be better if the driver survived
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1719 posts
If insurance companies reckon it's going to save them money by having done a defensive driving course, then that's a pretty good indicator that, in general, it's probably safer to have done it.
They don't give discounts to people who've done safe driving courses.
Only from skilled driving courses.
safe driving course - teaches you how to crash & manouver safely
skilled driver course - teaches you not to be an idiot
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3709 posts
Where do you do these courses? I heard RACQ but the thing I found on their site didn't look quite like what I was after.
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1720 posts
I did mine with AAMI. it was free and i got a 10% discount on insurance
|
fade
Brisbane, Queensland
4077 posts
^^ same here. I don't think I learnt anything at the course, though.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5417 posts
there's a driver training facility (I think it might even be the AAMI one) on Kingsford smith drive towards Pinkenba just before you get to the Bruce on ramp
|
d[o_0]b
Brisbane, Queensland
3507 posts
^^ confirmed i've done that, think it was free as well from AAMI
tbh you can do all the driving courses in the world but it still wont save you from being irresponsible ie drink driving/speeding
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5418 posts
that's the funny thing about common sense, it's not all that common
|
reload!
Brisbane, Queensland
5095 posts
I skipped to the end after half way but I don't understand how chub can be calling out auto drivers when he doesn't understand how to drive on the highway.
|
MatchFixa
Brisbane, Queensland
1904 posts
That'll buff right out.
|
CactusSupreme
Gold Coast, Queensland
60 posts
Back to the 80km/h restriction thing here. What about a P plater driving on a 110km/h road with bends and crests? And don't say there aren't any. Because alot of the roads heading westish from the GoldCoast are like that. But to the point, say a driver comes over a crest and around a bend at 100 and there is a P plater doing 80? Swerve off the road and hit a tree? Run up the P platers ass?
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1864 posts
Having P Platers doing 80k on the highway is fucking stupid. How is that learning how to drive? Its only going to cause problems with other drivers, and they will never learn how to pass people that are going slower, cause they are the ones going slower.
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6161 posts
is a P plater doing 80? Swerve off the road and hit a tree? Run up the P platers ass?
Shouldn't they be doing 80km/h anyway by law*? So what is the difference in this scenario?
Also the conditions you describe... if you can't see a car, or any potential hazard for that matter, that your approaching in enough time to take safe evasive action when doing 100km/h you are driving too fast for the conditions, regardless of what the maximum speed limit is.
*I don't know what current P-Plate restrictions are, still 80km/h?
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6162 posts
Oh and I think P-Platers should be restricted, just because you passed the licence test doesn't mean you can 'drive'.
And pulling out the 'it's not safe for others' is a load of shit. It would be far safer for someone with little experience to be driving at 80km/h than 110km/h if you can't work out why....
Sure you might be able to operate the vehicle and know basic raod rules but to become a good driver takes years> of experience that you only get with, you guessed it driving experience on the roads.
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
392 posts
Oh and I think P-Platers should be restricted, just because you passed the licence test doesn't mean you can 'drive'. And pulling out the 'it's not safe for others' is a load of shit.
so giving them a handicap helps them how...?
i think i like the way the victorian gov has handled new drivers, 120 hours minimum of experience which is a great way to force people for a decent time behind the wheel of a car before they can get a license. unfortunately those cunts who died had just missed the boat on that legislation.
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11069 posts
Back to the 80km/h restriction thing here. What about a P plater driving on a 110km/h road with bends and crests? And don't say there aren't any. Because alot of the roads heading westish from the GoldCoast are like that. But to the point, say a driver comes over a crest and around a bend at 100 and there is a P plater doing 80? Swerve off the road and hit a tree? Run up the P platers ass? there are no such roads where this can be an issue soley for this type of L/P speed restriction, in existence - you're imagining things
|
taggs
Brisbane, Queensland
3516 posts
this thread is so lol. i've seen a handful of reasonable posts, the rest is all "fuck i'm awesome at driving, touch my cock!"
and to all you retards suggesting that P-platers should be limited to 80km/h even on roads where the limit is 110 - the law of unintended consequences is a powerful thing. your kneejerk reaction could very possibly make the roads MORE unsafe according to some statistical analysis:
This paper presents evidence that speed laws should be viewed as devices for coordinating speed, not just limiting it. Both the slow driver and the fast one impose negative externalities on the median driver. Apparently, this is a novel conclusion: all current safety campaigns emphasise that "speed kills". They imply that the slower driver is the virtuous once and is helping protect himself and other drivers. It isn't so. To reduce fatalities, it is important that everyone drive at about the same speed. Thus the major consideration in choosing a speed limit is that it be obeyed. And the major consideration for the police is to reduce variance, not speed, because slow drivers are as much a public hazard as fast ones.
...
Although I have found no statistically discernable effect from speed, per se, this does not necessarily imply that it is safe to raise the speed limit, for we do not know what effect a higher limit would have on the speed variance. In the twelve data sets examined, there is generally a negative correlation between average speed and speed variance (8 negative, 3 positive and one 0.0); but I take these correlations to be suggestive rather than predictive
Lave, CE 1985, 'Speeding, Coordination and the 55mph Limit", The American Economic Review, vol. 75, no. 5, pp. 1159-1164
edit: fixing spelling, had to speed type that quote cause i couldn't copy paste from the .pdf :'( last edited by taggs at 09:04:05 19/Jan/10
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
393 posts
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4041 posts
this thread is so lol. i've seen a handful of reasonable posts
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6163 posts
so giving them a handicap helps them how...?
I really don't have to state the obvious do I, I mean really if you can't work that out.....
A small clue to point you in the right direction:
Ask yourself if there is a significant difference bewteen 80km/h and 110km/h.
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4042 posts
Ask yourself if there is a significant difference bewteen 80km/h and 110km/h.
Don't forget that it's velocity^2 in kinetic energy, so there's a huge diff.
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
394 posts
I really don't have to state the obvious do I, I mean really if you can't work that out..... A small clue to point you in the right direction: Ask yourself if there is a significant difference bewteen 80km/h and 110km/h.
yeah righto buddy. not too many roads down here that are 110 km/h unless you are on your way to ballarat... you're practically redneck so i'm not going to hold a grudge against your ignorance.
there are better ways to teach someone to drive rather than just slap a speed restriction on them. down here, you need 120hours MINIMUM before you can go for your license, and for your first year you can't have anyone between 18-21 in the car with you after 8pm (or something along those lines).
What better way to fucking learn how to drive than to practice?
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6164 posts
120hours MINIMUM before you can go for your license, and for your first year you can't have anyone between 18-21 in the car with you after 8pm (or something along those lines).
Fair enough, I don't know the rules in Victoria.
In QLD the main road to the Gold Coast (and beyond to Byron Bay) is 110 and up the sunshine coast I think there are stretches of 110 (been a long time since I've been up there). So, 110 is not uncommon in QLD.
My point is there is a significant difference in driving at 80 compared to 110 or even 100. Until you have significant experience driving a car at 80km/h you shouldn't be allowed to drive at 110km/h (which is 37% faster).
The main differences being braking distance, car handling, reaction time but most importantly is being aware of your surroundings. Like spotting the fucktard weaving in traffic behind you (you will then come up behind you), the dumb blonde wandering out of her lane while changing cd's or the potential of traffic slowing suddenly in front of you.
I think having this awareness comes with expereince of driving and when driving at 110 your reaction time to these events is significantly reduced compared to when you are driving at 80 - hence until you have experience you should be reduced to 80 until your driving skills (not just operating the vehicle - start, stop, steer) have improved.
|
Mephz
Brisbane, Queensland
276 posts
I think the other issue is that most P-Platers just have shit vehicles as it's their first car.
Though, I do believe the no turbo and no v8 until 25 rule (or was it until opens?) has improved the quality of most vehicles I see P Platers driving around on...
|
infi
Brisbane, Queensland
14925 posts
and reduced the amount of damage they inflict.
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9990 posts
I think the other issue is that most P-Platers just have shit vehicles as it's their first car.
Not sure what you mean by "shit vehicles", but there's a well known trend whereby the safer cars are made, the more dangerously people drive. Imagine how carefully people would drive if, for example, instead of an airbag there was a huge metal spike.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29003 posts
And conversely, imagine how non-carefully they would drive if they were in a tank.
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3464 posts
Not sure what you mean by "shit vehicles", but there's a well known trend whereby the safer cars are made, the more dangerously people drive. Imagine how carefully people would drive if, for example, instead of an airbag there was a huge metal spike
Is this the bumper bar / 4wd mentality?
|
MatchFixa
Brisbane, Queensland
1907 posts
Don't forget that it's velocity^2 in kinetic energy, so there's a huge diff.
yeah yeah but when are you going to start touching my cock?
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5429 posts
Not sure what you mean by "shit vehicles", but there's a well known trend whereby the safer cars are made, the more dangerously people drive.
Nah I don't know about that, not for the majority of the population
I drive my mums Barina the same way I drive my ute, I'm 10x more likely to die in the Barina
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9991 posts
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1721 posts
I think having this awareness comes with expereince of driving and when driving at 110 your reaction time to these events is significantly reduced compared to when you are driving at 80
Personally I think that awareness is to be practiced at all speeds. Limiting me to 80 will just restrict the amount of learning I can do, and make me a more dangerous driver once I get my Ps off. (ie; congrats, you've finished your Ps, now try and get on a 110 road and do something you've never practiced before!)
It's like a teacher educating grade 7'ers on addition and restricting them from learning multiplication. We are fully capable, and teaching us at 80km/h will not prepare us adequately for higher speeds. On 110 roads the only thing that will make us safer is practical experience. Practice and good teaching. last edited by Phooks at 12:56:22 19/Jan/10
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1722 posts
Next you will be saying we should be restriced to 45 in 60 zones because the speed change is not so noticeable that our judgement at both speeds will be comparable enough that we still learn from it. There is a MASSIVE difference between 80 and 110. (which is why it is a safer drive)
TLDR; If you baby us, we will drive like babies when we are unrestricted.
last edited by Phooks at 12:55:19 19/Jan/10
|
Hogfather
Cairns, Queensland
4834 posts
Your research links mean nothing compared to teq's Barina anecdotes Billy!
|
Mephz
Brisbane, Queensland
277 posts
We get it Phooks... It could not or would not effect you if it even happened tomorrow with that suggestion anyway, so, enough already please with the rebellious posts.
Now, what I meant by shit vehicles was that the amount of old VK etc. commodores that look like they're falling apart with multi-panels and such with young drivers in them seems to have decreased.
The Peltzman effect may be true, but take a 17 year old who's going to drift sideways through an intersection, they're going to do it regardless if the car has airbags or not.
At least in the newer car there's an increased chance of survival.
Better yet, the government should just enforce power to weight restrictions (or did they change to this from the Turbo/V8 rule?) as they do for motorbikes.
Doesn't need to be speed limited if the car doesn't have the power to get to 180km/h in the first place - and at least certainly not quickly.
last edited by Mephz at 12:57:52 19/Jan/10
|
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1723 posts
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9992 posts
The Peltzman effect may be true, but take a 17 year old who's going to drift sideways through an intersection, they're going to do it regardless if the car has airbags or not.
Contradicted yourself, sort of :) If the 17 year old is going to do it regardless, the research would suggest that they will take the corner slightly faster (for example) if they have an airbag.
|
Mephz
Brisbane, Queensland
278 posts
I forgot to mention, a long side power:weight restrictions, Provisionals caught driving a vehicle outside the listed/accepted power:weight/cars should be a loss of licence for minimum 12 months, plus commandeering of the vehicle and auctioning it off.
Would of course include modifications performance or otherwise.
(No exhaust/muffler mods, no nothing - car must be as factory or to factory specifications in terms of dB exhaust noise etc.).
This should go for anybody on a provisional licence, whether they are 30... 40... or 50 and on a provisional.
It's what, 3 years of P's unless over 25, in which case its 1 year? IIRC?
That makes persons 20 when they can get a modded car.
Sounds like a reasonable idea on rough paper.
Contradicted yourself, sort of :) If the 17 year old is going to do it regardless, the research would suggest that they will take the corner slightly faster (for example) if they have an airbag. Not really, I can guarantee 'this car has airbags, I'll try and do this drift faster' will not have entered their minds.
Having done that sort of stuff when I too was 17 and my friends also, I can attest that this never entered our heads.
It was all about learning what the car can do or showing off :)
Both of which, of course are bad, fortunately we had some sense to keep it to industrial areas after hours for the most part.
last edited by Mephz at 13:09:04 19/Jan/10
|
Mephz
Brisbane, Queensland
279 posts
Oh, I wouldn't mind seeing the whether those cars which are more likely to be involved in higher risk maneuvers due to increased safety standards, actually have a higher power:weight, or just more powerful in general due to technology also.
|
fpot
Gold Coast, Queensland
16967 posts
Phooks
Brisbane, Queensland
1724 posts
 ahahaha mephz
you used to fuck around drifting illegally when you were my age and you're the one calling my posts on an online forum "rebellious"
fuck off
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6403 posts
well i dunno about this peltzman fella but when i drive a more powerful car, i drive slower. simply because i have nothing to prove anymore, it's all there.
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
395 posts
Contradicted yourself, sort of :) If the 17 year old is going to do it regardless, the research would suggest that they will take the corner slightly faster (for example) if they have an airbag.
i hate when billy comes in with his "research". yes you work at a uni mate, that doesn't make you better than everyone.
give us a reference for once. how the hell did he contradict himself? why should i take your word for it?
EDIT: i'll be humbled if you provide this research :D
|
Mephz
Brisbane, Queensland
280 posts
I'm not carrying on about how I need a powerful car and that if laws are introduced I'm going to drive like a fool to intentional piss everyone off and 'stick it to the man'.
Its the attitude that you have, and I had, at that age, that proves why power:weight and zero-modification laws should exist.
If those laws were introduced they'd affect only those obtaining their p's, not those who already have them.
Much the same as P's who already owned V8's or Turbo's were not forced to sell their vehicle when that law was introduced. Nor were P's forced to display P plates if they already had their P's before the law changed. (That last one I'm not 100% on, but the former most definately).
So, why you're carrying on over something which wouldn't affect you, and is hypothetical........
last edited by Mephz at 13:25:00 19/Jan/10
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6171 posts
Personally I think that awareness is to be practiced at all speeds. Limiting me to 80 will just restrict the amount of learning I can do, and make me a more dangerous driver once I get my Ps off. (ie; congrats, you've finished your Ps, now try and get on a 110 road and do something you've never practiced before!)
It limits your learning to a safer speed so if you make a bad decision, which you will everybody does while learning, the chances of you still avoiding an accident or should an accident occur reducing injury.
What you have learned driving at 80 for 12 months (or whatever it is) better equips you for handling situations at a higher speed, that is the practise.
Most things in life are based on experience. The more you have the better you are at the task. To gain this experience you don't need to be thrown in the 'deep end' as such.
ie: Responsible jobs require people with demonstrated experience because they don't want things to get fucked up. Should a uni IT graduate run the treasuries IT system just to gain experience? No, they build up to the task through training and on the job experience until they have the necessary skills to safely handle situations.
Anyway this is going no where fast (pun intended).
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3466 posts
konstie read 6 posts above Billy's last where he provided links
i hate when billy comes in with his "research". yes you work at a uni mate, that doesn't make you better than everyone.
Yes but it does mean he uses evidence as opposed to anecdotes to form his opinion, something that a lot of people seem to struggle with... last edited by imitation at 13:45:55 19/Jan/10
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11072 posts
give us a reference for once. wot? he almost always does
|
reload!
Brisbane, Queensland
5097 posts
haha I love how he put research in inverted commas. as if to say it's actually intellectual propaganda being spread by that pesky billyhardball with his "education" and "informed opinion".
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3467 posts
Billy's part of the intellectual elite the closest he's been to a car is a segway
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
396 posts
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
397 posts
eightyeight
Brisbane, Queensland
1260 posts
fuck yeah fpot imagine if every car came standard with a roll cage. If they really wanted to save lives on the road that's what cars need, not laws.
Yet the law states if you get a 6 point cage or more you get defected. WTF.
|
neffo
Forum Hero
Wynnum, Queensland
16209 posts
Don't start going down that route, or before you know it Anna Bligh will force us to wear Nomex and motorcycle helmets to drive to the corner store.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29006 posts
fuck yeah fpot imagine if every car came standard with a roll cage. If they really wanted to save lives on the road that's what cars need, not laws. while we're imagining awesome alternate universes, I'd like to imagine one where we could buy cheap, small one-seater cars, so that instead of everyone whizzing around in huge heavy gas-guzzling vehicles that are stuffed with heaps of kinetic energy, everyone is in small lightweight dodgem cars
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6408 posts
i'm pretty sure you're meaning a motorbike or a getz trog
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5430 posts
I used to drive the shit out of all my cars (before I grew up a bit), regardless of airbags
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11074 posts
I dunno trog, that seems far more airy-fairy than cars coming with roll cages
considering that many modern vehicles do achieve similar or better effect by building a rollcage-style structure into the roof/sides already
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4061 posts
The next big topic (not yet in Aus) in occupant safety is active safety. The entry point to active safety is 'early intervention' - that is the 0 to ½ second before the accident occurs. You can accurately detect that an accident is imminent in this time-frame and take action such as brake with maximum force (higher and more efficiently than a person can) and tighten the belt retractor to pull the occupant into a desirable configuration, stuff like that.
Additional sensors required to detect collisions are standard CCTV and laser interferometers, already on the market in luxury vehicles.
Following this the next thing will be car-to-car communication (C2C). This is exactly what it sounds like. Each vehicle knows the position and linear and angular derivatives of the other vehicles. This will take a long time to be implemented, but it will be implemented.
Once these systems are in place it's going to be pretty difficult for someone to write you off.
|
neffo
Forum Hero
Wynnum, Queensland
16210 posts
Are trees going to be fitted with this technology as well?
|
imitation
Brisbane, Queensland
3470 posts
Following this the next thing will be car-to-car communication (C2C).
I want to be able to tell other drivers exactly what I think of them, some how I predict it would result in more accidents though
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5434 posts
prediction: someone hacks car2car to make other cars think they're about to be impacted
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4064 posts
Are trees going to be fitted with this technology as well?
Yes. And small- to medium-sized puppies, kittens and budgerigars.
http://www.car-to-car.org/
|
Thundercracker
Brisbane, Queensland
2232 posts
Would have been handy for that pedestrian that walked out on to sandgate road and got potatowned a few months ago.
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5071 posts
here is my totally unrelated story of road safety. it contains neither dragons or ninjas so it's not for those of you with a.d.d.
i live on a busy 2 lane road that runs vaguely east-west. it's approximately 120 metres to the closest traffic lights to the east & about 90 metres to the west so i am basically in the middle point between 2 sets of lights.
recently the council decided that the area was a 'black spot' for accidents... i don't know how they came to this conclusion as i have lived there for over 10years & i have only seen 1 car accident where a dude ran up the back of a neighbour who was turning into his driveway. the councils first move to combat this evil black spot was to put a pedestrian 'safety' island right in front of my fucking driveway. 2 weeks after it was installed a car ran over a pedestrian that thought it was a marked crossing. it wasn't. the car didn't even slow down n killed the pedestrian. a few weeks later another accident, this time 2 kids are put in hospital with serious injuries... same deal... they thought they could cross without looking, the car driver didn't think he had to stop.
so the council decide it's time to take action!! they put signs up saying "no parking" outside my fucking house :/ 2 nights later a drunk driver mounts the traffic island busting up the signs n rolls his commie onto it's roof. the car comes to rest in front of my new 'no parking' signs :| i write a letter to the mains roads dept saying i that i think they have created a problem. a week later i get a letter back that thanks me for my concern but the plans for the bus lane have already been approved & are going ahead despite my concerns. i check the details of the letter... they mean a bus lane that's more than 4 blocks away from me :/
so now i got this shitty busted up traffic island with the broken stubs of it's former sign posts that makes it a pain to turn right out of my driveway & no on-street parking. the other night i wake up at about 3am coz i can hear kids being noisy... look out the window n there is 3 drunk teens sitting on the traffic island shrieking in their shrill drunk teeny voices... a bit further down some folk are crossing the road about halfway between the island n the set of lights !$!@!@#$!
tldr : no matter what you do to try & make _everyone_ safer... some people will seemingly go out of their way to make it even more dangerous than before !@#! also the council really seem like dopes.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5444 posts
dude, hire a jack hamer and just get rid of it yourself
fuck having a traffic island right outside your house
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11077 posts
fuckin hell demon
that's just so typical
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4066 posts
demon, the only solution is to enter council politics. Do it.
|
re so
I can't read
Brisbane, Queensland
4954 posts
clearly they should just make all cars & 4wd's illegal and make everybody ride motorbikes? :D
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5445 posts
with steel spikes in the event of a fail?
RIDE STRAIGHT OR DIE!@!@
|
taggs
Brisbane, Queensland
3517 posts
It's well researched, and it's known as the Peltzman effect.
also known as moral hazard in economic jargon. very heavily researched in that field too.
|
Dazhel
Gold Coast, Queensland
711 posts
also the council really seem like dopes.
Well that's always a constant isn't it.
|
justrev
Melbourne, Victoria
45 posts
When I got my licence we were told it was a bad idea to be taught by our parents how to drive.
They just teach you their bad habits.
So booking up hours of training with bad and speeding drivers = fail
So many people inching their way over the line drawn by the law, of course young drivers will push further.
Thus every speeding driver and every jay walker is contributing to this. No matter how safe you think you yourself may be.
photos available on request
|
Any
Brisbane, Queensland
386 posts
So, turns out this dickhead had a bac of 0.19. Nearly 4x the legal limit for a fully licensed driver.
What the fucking fuck is wrong with people? At what point do we label this as a murder suicide?
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
9994 posts
When I got my licence we were told it was a bad idea to be taught by our parents how to drive.
They just teach you their bad habits.
So booking up hours of training with bad and speeding drivers = fail
I reckon if you have grown up with a bad driver for a parent, you're likely to adopt a lot of their habits regardless of who teaches you.
So many people inching their way over the line drawn by the law, of course young drivers will push further.
Thus every speeding driver and every jay walker is contributing to this. No matter how safe you think you yourself may be.
Agreed. And this is why it shits me when people say "I know how my car handles at fast speeds" and "I can drive safely at faster speeds".
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6176 posts
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4082 posts
At what point do we label this as a murder suicide?
I reckon that's a really valid point. At least manslaughter anyway.
Also, can you charge people posthumously? And if so, what is the implication (if any) for the existing family with regards to the guys debt (no doubt he had some, with that car being so young).
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29012 posts
i'm pretty sure you're meaning a motorbike or a getz trog yeh I was pretty much imagining those Asian countries where you see TV footage of their roads, and its like 99% scooters So, turns out this dickhead had a bac of 0.19. Nearly 4x the legal limit for a fully licensed driver.
What the fucking fuck is wrong with people? At what point do we label this as a murder suicide? that is fucking lame
if it was just himself we could at least say, think of it as evolution in action, but yes, if he survived he should be going to jail for the rest of his life
|
Any
Brisbane, Queensland
387 posts
So I was thinking... how difficult would it be to implement a black box for motor vehicles? Surely police & insurance companies would get behind the idea, and knowing that every action you take is being recorded & could be used against you in court or by your insurance agency would motivate people to be on their best behaviour?
Though would it stop a retarded teenage P plater from driving at 170km/h with a bac of .19? Probably not :(
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29014 posts
So I was thinking... how difficult would it be to implement a black box for motor vehicles? Surely police & insurance companies would get behind the idea, and knowing that every action you take is being recorded & could be used against you in court or by your insurance agency would motivate people to be on their best behaviour? Such devices already exist (at least in concept/testing) in the US.
IIRC the way they work is they track your driving habits and if you never speed, etc, you get lower insurance premiums.
i can't find the exact story I read, but here's a related one: http://yro.slashdot.org/story/09/09/13/0045257/Trust-an-Insurance-Companys-Drive-Cam
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6177 posts
It would have to be tricky to know if you're speeding or not as it would have to know the speed limit for the section of road you're driving on to determine this.
I guess some sort of built in GPS matching against a speed limit database :/
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5077 posts
a while back a quango from the the fed govt approached the company i work for to develop a device that monitors vehicle speed & compares it with the posted speed limit of the road & logs differences. the cops could access the logs to assign traffic infringement notices. the project was scrapped when it was discovered how much it would cost to develop a unit that could be retro-fitted to every sort of vehicle. it was also almost impossible to guarantee the device to be tamper-proof.
|
Any
Brisbane, Queensland
389 posts
I can understand that demon, and retrofitting may be infeasible. But to have it made mandatory on all new cars would be a start, and while the device may be able to be tampered with, surely the tampering could be made obvious & thus void your insurance / raise authorities suspicion. I'd suggest it would be difficult to generate realistic unique data that would be hard to detect.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5454 posts
It would have to be tricky to know if you're speeding or not as it would have to know the speed limit for the section of road you're driving on to determine this.
easy to do in the event of a claim though, they could just plot your course and if you're doing 100km/hr anywhere near a residential street you are pretty much boned
not many places in residential areas where you can do 80, let alone 100
except of course areas like the ICB etc, but that could be determined by overlaying the gps coords on a map
So, turns out this dickhead had a bac of 0.19
all sympathy for him just went out the window, it's just a shame that he killed 4 innocent people
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5078 posts
mandatory on all new vehicles is even more difficult... because then you have to get every vehicle manufacturer to agree on the devices standards... this is next to impossible. the manufacturers will push for the system that suits their products the best & will never agree to increase their own price to make it easier for another manufacturer.
the tampering issue is also not easy. people are fucking resourceful critters! a user could smash the device with a rock & claim that in the normal operation of the vehicle a rock smashed the device. this sort of tamper is easily detected but while the device is not operating the user is unmonitored. the device could be exposed to high voltage shock, destructive vibration, powerful magnetic fields, etc... as no manufacturer can guarantee reliability then there is no way to prove that the device wasn't made faulty. the user doesn't need to fabricate data... they just need the device to stop working.
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29015 posts
the project was scrapped when it was discovered how much it would cost to develop a unit that could be retro-fitted to every sort of vehicle. it was also almost impossible to guarantee the device to be tamper-proof. Yeh I think the way the US mob were doing it was the right way. Rather than make it mandatory and make everyone absorb the cost, people could opt-in to the system if they were interested in saving money on their insurance by driving carefully.
I would opt-in to a system like that in a second. I barely drive at all, I do my best all the time to not speed. My insurance should be half the cost of what it is based on how much I drive.
|
Any
Brisbane, Queensland
390 posts
Fair enough demon, though I was going the "it aint working, u aint insured" kind of route. Make the user responsible. I know this is gliding over a number of difficult issues however.
The thing is, no matter what, no one is going to ban alcohol or cars, so the only options are better policing, better deterrents (death isn't good enough), or better physical prevention.
|
Martz
Brisbane, Queensland
2506 posts
all sympathy for him just went out the window, it's just a shame that he killed 4 innocent people
according to thermite, the 4 passengers that died are bogans that are just as bad and deserving of death as the driver.
Car full of wankers + high speed. I actually wish death upon people I see driving like that.
innocent my arse, you get into a xr6 with an underage drunk roof tiler who aspires to be a rap-star, that has a recent speeding conviction, with FIVE OTHER PEOPLE, at a party, and then you hang out the window while he speeds along yelling and screaming and carrying on and doing the finger to the drivers behind you, you deserve what you get.
Bullshit bullshit bullshit. I was 17 once too, and I wasn't a fucking bogan idiot. Even years before I got my licence I knew not to do something stupid like this. I never drove with passengers in the car, I never even told anybody I HAD a car, I parked the motherfucker 3 blocks away.
And no I don't "thrash the old 350" NOW either, whatever the fuck that means.
They don't deserve it? Oh well maybe every teenager should drive like idiots then, go for it!
A lot more shit drivers deserve to die, perhaps even you and your 350 (again, wtf). last edited by Martz at 12:57:43 20/Jan/10
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4089 posts
I would opt-in to a system like that in a second. I barely drive at all, I do my best all the time to not speed. My insurance should be half the cost of what it is based on how much I drive.
Ok, the GSM unit, accelerometer and gyro (accurate velocity measurement) and micro-controller and associated electronics are all very cheap.
The problem is determine if you are speeding.
Let's say you're traveling 100 in a 60 zone. How does the system know you're in a 60 zone? You could add a GPS to the system (cheap) which is accurate to 10m - then the insurance company has a DB of all speed-zones - so if you are doing 80 in a zone they think is a 60 zone then there's a problem.
Negative of this is that the GSM system needs to update the insurance company regularly (lots of processing = cost).
Best would be to determine on the vehicle if you are over the speed limit for that area and ONLY inform the insurance company in that situation. There's a few ways that would be possible. To determine current speed limit on the vehicle you could use CCTV to interpret the speed signs (very doable, a few studies have shown that's possible with Aussie road-signs). You could also have 'blanket areas' where transmitters mounted on private property (cost) communicate with the vehicles to inform them of the local speed-zone - also doable but seems prone to error and high maintenance costs.
Ultimately though it's a cost-benefit analysis for the insurance company. They need to know how many of their accidents are caused by speeding, and if it's actually worth coming up with all this bullshit to save some significant coin.
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5079 posts
personally, i reckon the current system is pretty good... ie: fines & demerit points. the only change i would like to see is harsher penalties for people that are actually involved in an accident & found to be at fault. as far as i know people in this situation are often only charged with a regular traffic infringment notice... but in my books being caught speeding isn't the same thing as actually being the cause of an accident. people that actually cause an accident should get hammered hard!
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11091 posts
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5455 posts
I would opt-in to a system like that in a second. I barely drive at all, I do my best all the time to not speed. My insurance should be half the cost of what it is based on how much I drive.
get a quote from www.youi.com.au
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29017 posts
that would require me to do things, when I could just bitch about it on the Internet
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5458 posts
while you're just giving away money then, I could always use a new ivory back scratcher..
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3736 posts
all sympathy for him just went out the window, it's just a shame that he killed 4 innocent people
see Martz post above for why those people not innocent.
Add to what I said: he had a 0.19 BAC, that isn't 'a bit' drunk, that is OBVIOUSLY drunk and the passengers would have known.
Those people were all hoons, whether they were steering the fucking thing, or not.
|
Jen
Melbourne, Victoria
11 posts
goodness... and it turns out apparently the driver had been drink driving... tsk tsk..
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3737 posts
I would go so far as to say the crash may not have happened without the passengers.
|
Hogfather
Cairns, Queensland
4862 posts
as far as i know people in this situation are often only charged with a regular traffic infringment notice... but in my books being caught speeding isn't the same thing as actually being the cause of an accident. people that actually cause an accident should get hammered hard!
If you're at fault in an accident and you are wilfully playing up don't you get belted with neg driving charges?
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4095 posts
If you're at fault in an accident and you are wilfully playing up don't you get belted with neg driving charges?
Yes.
It just comes back to the same old boring bullshit - the law is far too lenient for common offenses.
Even if you want to increase the penalties - what are they?
Crush the car, for example - what's that going to achieve? The dude gets sacked cos he can't get to work and then we have another jobless low-life with no responsibility spiraling downwards and burdening society with their juvenile existence.
Lock them up? At what cost to tax-payers?
Higher demerit points - clearly such people don't give a shit.
I think there are no good solutions for the people that were in this accident.
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6178 posts
What about public stoning?
|
demon
Brisbane, Queensland
5081 posts
If you're at fault in an accident and you are wilfully playing up don't you get belted with neg driving charges?
i'm guessing it would depend on the situation. from my own experience... i had a dude run into the back of me while i was waiting at a set of red traffic lights. the collision threw me (& my bike) into the intersection & i only narrowly avoided being run over by oncoming traffic by my ninja skills.
apart from having to pay for the damages to my bike the dude didn't get into any trouble. even though i knew he was speeding, not paying attention & would have run a red light except i was in his way... i had no way to prove any of that except the fact that he hit me.
so my point would be that by being at fault in the event of an accident, you should be given a harsher penalty than other traffic offences that only _might_ cause an accident.
Even if you want to increase the penalties - what are they?
higher fine, more demerit points.
Higher demerit points - clearly such people don't give a shit.
i disagree. i think that anyone licensed does care about demerit points.
last edited by demon at 14:16:16 20/Jan/10
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5461 posts
of course you do, and if you kill someone you're almost always charged with culpable driving causing death
i think he means like, when you're speeding down the highway and you dont stop in time for a traffic jam up ahead + you run into the back of someone
you might get a slap on the wrist even though you were obviously going too fast
its all just too hard to prove though, unless there are police on site
|
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29020 posts
apart from having to pay for the damages to my bike the dude didn't get into any trouble. even though i knew he was speeding, not paying attention & would have run a red light except i was in his way... i had no way to prove any of that except the fact that he hit me.
so my point would be that by being at fault in the event of an accident, you should be given a harsher penalty than other traffic offences that only _might_ cause an accident. Holy fuck
that dude should have lost his license instantly
|
Hogfather
Cairns, Queensland
4867 posts
Yeh no shit! But an anecdote doesn't prove the general case.
I do agree though that fucking up while driving and pranging should in general be stomped on, and if its not then it needs to be.
|
neffo
Forum Hero
Wynnum, Queensland
16216 posts
How I'll run the state when I become king:
* mandatory 3rd party property insurance
* like demon said, at fault driver penalties. mandatory reporting of insurance claims. 3 points per at fault accident. 3 months suspension of license in case of an injury/major accident. penalties are cumulative with previous penalties within a rolling 3 year period. 2 minor accidents in 3 years = 3 + 3 (+ 3) = 9 points, same with suspensions.
* acquiring a taxi license requires holding an open (australian) license for no less than 1 year.
* fines and demerit points for dangerously under-speed vehicles on specific motorways (eg M1). underpowered vehicles must take alternative routes. obviously, they need to exist for this to be enforceable.
* (off-topic) mandatory jail terms for assault. if cunts want to punch on in nightclubs and pubs, they can do that shit in the prison showers instead. could work for road rage, too.
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
401 posts
congratulations, you've just run the country to the ground.
just kidding.
although, while i half agree about holding a full license for a year before becoming a cabbie, i disagree because it'll limit what semi-skilled migrants can get as a first job.
|
neffo
Forum Hero
Wynnum, Queensland
16218 posts
Driving is a skill, its not a right.
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
402 posts
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4100 posts
Thundercracker
Brisbane, Queensland
2236 posts
* mandatory 3rd party property insurance
It surprises me that people drive around without this. Some dude ran into the back of the missus' car (P plater on his iPhone) and didn't have this. Now for a simple mistake he is going to be out of pocket a hefty sum. Insuring his little fiesta would have cost 100-200 bucks a year. Imagine if he rear ended an expensive car that cost $10k or more to fix.
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6180 posts
Pffft, last audit they did they found plenty of taxi drivers who weren't even licensed (taxi license, not necessarily driving).
You can make as many rules as you want, doesn't mean they will be enforced or people will follow them.
Surely their employer (the taxi company) would have some sort of liability/responsibility in that situation. I think some cabs are privately owned(?) but still to have Yellow plastered across the car implies some sort of relationship and represenation of the company.
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6418 posts
mission: 9 times out of 10 the drivers won't get away with it. Dispatch company owned cabs most certainly won't let it happen, and fleet cars won't let it happen with regular bailee drivers.
However you get unique situations called 'set-pay-in' cabs where a taxi base owns the licence, the cab, the everything, and says give us say $1400 and you can keep the cab for a week. If you take $1, then you lose, and if you take $4000 (which is actually rather do-able) you win. Obviously no driver can work for 7 days and nights straight, so you'll get a bunch of mates (especially ethnic minority groups), either 3 or 4 of them driving the cab for that period, with probably only 2 of them who actually hold taxi driver licences. So the dispatch company believes that bobby bob drove 7x12hrs and billy bill drover 7x12hrs, but in fact there was sammy sam and reggie reg, both unlicenced, who drove on bob's and bill's licence for a portion of that 7 day period. The dispatch company doesn't know, the cab's owners don't know, only when the DOT comes knocking at the queen street rank do they find out what's the go.
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4111 posts
But hardware, what's the mechanism whereby they actually check?
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6183 posts
Also,
Bobby Bob
Billy Bill
Sammy Sam
Reggie Reg
I suspect you made up those names, maybe to protect the innocent, or in this case, the guilty.
Be a good citizan and rat them out.
It probably also explains how shit the cab system is, or used to be. No fucker would turn up when you rang or when you tried to flag 'em down on the street.
The service was so shit it was shocking.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5477 posts
yeah, fucking cab drivers !!!!1
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1878 posts
While we are talking about crashes, this is what happened to me a few weeks back.
Im the Grey line, 4wd is the Blue line, Suburu is the red line, if that makes sense.
I was in the mazda 3. Dude in the 4wd was coming up the hill, lost control into my lane, he hit the suburu who I was following in the rear drivers door, spun the suburu into the guard rail, he continued onto my side of the road, I jumped on the brakes and turned into the other lane to avoid him, but as you can see in the second pic, I clipped his back bumper just behind his wheel.
What pissed me off most about this whole incident was the police, they took over an hour to get there from when I called 000. I drive this road everyday to work and they are constantly booking people on this road, yet when we actualy need them they take there fucken time.
The 2 other people went off in the ambulance and I stupidly didnt get the name of the guy driving the 4wd, I guess I wasnt thinking straight and it was a bit of a mad scene with being on the phone to 000 and then dealing with the lady driving the suburu who was realy old and she was a bit shaken up.
Anyway, I though not to worry ive got pictures and the rego's and the police eventually turned up and got all the details. Ill call the police, get the report number (cause as the policeman told me they cant tell you the name of the driver at fault for "privacy" reasons) give the report number to my insurance and they will handle it all.
Nope, the insurance said they have to try and track down the owner becuase the police report doesnt include the name of the driver of the 4wd, not because they cant give out, but because the police just didnt have it. The police turned up after the guy had left in the ambulance, and the police just didnt bother to find out who was driving the 4wd, guess it wasnt important, he only just caused a major 3 car accidnt and closed a road for over an hour.
The police dont give a fuck about actualy stopping accidents, this guy should have been booked, he should have lost his licence for at least 3 months. He was either in a defective car and lost control or he was going to fast, or was just a shit driver, either way this is worse than speeding, but the police dont give a fuck. Imagine how much work it would be to fine this guy, at least a few hours work. They could be out on the road booking people for 75 in a 70 zone and acutaly saving lives.
Fuckers.
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1879 posts
Oh yeah, I obviously didnt end up where the car is pictured, I moved down the road a bit cause I was on the wrong side of the road, and I drove round the corner a bit so cars coming up the hill would see me with my hazards on.
|
BillyHardball
Brisbane, Queensland
10003 posts
The police dont give a fuck about actualy stopping accidents, this guy should have been booked, he should have lost his licence for at least 3 months. He was either in a defective car and lost control or he was going to fast, or was just a shit driver, either way this is worse than speeding, but the police dont give a fuck. Imagine how much work it would be to fine this guy, at least a few hours work. They could be out on the road booking people for 75 in a 70 zone and acutaly saving lives.
I'm sympathetic to your situation, but taking his name wouldn't have prevented your accident, and hopefully the driver would have been given enough of a scare so that he drives more safely in future...
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5479 posts
you can walk into any cop shop with someones rego details and tell them you've been in an accident with that person, you would like to get their license details (of the vehicle owner/registration)
I've done it on more than one occasion
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4130 posts
When I had my bad accident a few years back someone at the scene called the coppers and they handled everything. I didn't take any details down myself.
It's bullshit that the cops didn't get the driver's name man - they ALWAYS give you a breath test down here if you have an accident and the cops are called. The rule of thumb is if there is more than $300 damage (i.e., always) you can call the cops.
The police report also assigns fault so it's a no-brainer for the insurance companies.
I'd be lodging a complaint about the police to the ombudsman over that, `ViPER`
|
Spook
Brisbane, Queensland
27757 posts
ive never had an accident when im driving (23 years) becuase im a fucking awesome driver
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6430 posts
I don't think i've ever come across a toyota surf driver who can actually properly handle their vehicle. They are extremely poor dynamically.
Viper, don't tell me the mazda 3 is your own private car. If it is, did you get the matching handbag?
|
thermite
Brisbane, Queensland
3748 posts
I got smashed by a truck on rode rd roundabout, ripped my driver's door off. I called like 3 police stations, nobody came. I even got a mention on the radio traffic report. In the end the tow truck driver had to clean the glass and shit off the road. PS I never found the truck driver.
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4132 posts
lol @ hardware. I'd buy a Mazda 3, Viper, ignore that bogan with the STP logo as his avatar.
ive never had an accident when im driving (23 years) becuase im a fucking awesome driver
Yeah well the bitch pulled out right in front of me from a T-junction without giving way. If someone does that to you one day we'll see if you think that's your fault or not ;-)
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
404 posts
my mate copped a fine for not reporting his car accident cause the cop station didn't pickup his phonecalls. Ha!
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6438 posts
ooh its on like donkey kong pinky
I suspect you made up those names, maybe to protect the innocent, or in this case, the guilty. Haha yeah. Although when i was in the cab game, there was a bobby, billy, sammy and reggie. Most commonly Barry, Peter and John however, half the white cab drivers on the road were named that. last edited by hardware at 11:54:45 21/Jan/10
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5480 posts
you don't have to report an accident to the police unless there is 3rd party property damage, ie council gardens / sign posts / someones fence etc
and if there is injury to anyone
I don't think i've ever come across a toyota surf driver who can actually properly handle their vehicle. They are extremely poor dynamically.
very common problem with surfs is suspension sag, they handle like a bucket of poo because they are
|
Jim
Brisbane, Queensland
11103 posts
hardware wants to be a bogan, he just started it recently
pretty funny
|
Spook
Brisbane, Queensland
27761 posts
Yeah well the bitch pulled out right in front of me from a T-junction without giving way.
im always on ninja alert when im driving, i never assume im going to get right of way, because people are idiots;
im always scanning, never assuming.
driving the davwoo has only heightened my ninja driving senses (due to its poor crash rating, im dodging trucks like a mofo)
the above combined with me completing dirt2 as a level 72 rally driver with 100% completion (and being great mates with ken block) leads me to believe i am the best driver on qgl. last edited by Spook at 12:03:43 21/Jan/10
|
Any
Brisbane, Queensland
391 posts
oh dear
This place sounds like an awesome area to go for a drive or take a relaxing stroll down the street...
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6440 posts
hardware wants to be a bogan, he just started it recently
pretty funny
you're actually kinda right there jim
except i'm kinda failing, i don't smoke/hardly drink/don't steal/earn good money/wear a shirt/don't have tattoos/have a job/have a mortgage and neatly cut grass/don't have unit stickers/shave every day/vote liberal
about the only thing that makes me a bogan is that i drive a nice falcon?
last edited by hardware at 12:04:41 21/Jan/10
/get a short back and sides every 6 weeks/ last edited by hardware at 12:06:53 21/Jan/10
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6189 posts
You can quiet easily grow a mullet though.
|
Spook
Brisbane, Queensland
27762 posts
you are still pretty bogan, you know, with the northside living n that
last edited by Spook at 12:06:58 21/Jan/10
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6441 posts
^coming from a labor voting/industrial area living/govt money grabbing old man?
|
Spook
Brisbane, Queensland
27763 posts
im entitled to that money!!!!!!
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4135 posts
You guys are all mega-North-side compared to where us cultured folk live.
Also, for the uninitiated, Mill Park is bogan central. A 3-bed house there costs $350k compared to $450k elsewhere - that kind of suburb. Not horribly rank or anything, but just a bit bogan.
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6191 posts
trog
AGN Admin
Brisbane, Queensland
29049 posts
It just gets better :/ Man all the people from that circle sure seem like prime candidates for export to other countries
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1883 posts
Spook, I pretty much did everything I could to avoid this accident, I was following at a safe distance, wasnt speeding, but if someone comes onto your side of the road without about 0 seconds notice and its raining, theres only so much you can do, as you can see the lady in the suburu had no chance of avoiding the accident, she was hit on the side as she passed an oncoming car, i only copped minimal damage and almost missed the surf, but not quite. I'd like to think im a pretty decent driver.
Hardware, its my wifes car, I was only driving it cause she was on holidays and its a much nicer car to drive than my Hilux 4runner (being diesel its not the fastest thing in the world) Ive got an un registered EB Fairmont in the shed if that means anything?
The guy in the suburu didnt have fully comp insurance so he was having to sort out getting his car fixed himself, he rang me to get see if I had the details on the 4wd, cause he had rung the police and they didnt know/care who was driving the 4wd, even though the police told me that the 4wd was name as the person at fault in the report.
We ended up getting the guys Insurance company name and claim number, with zero help from the police.
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6444 posts
ah ok viper
i didn't imagine you'd be the kind of bloke to own a car like that
EB monty hey? what you gonna do with it?
|
`ViPER`
Brisbane, Queensland
1884 posts
ah ok viper
i didn't imagine you'd be the kind of bloke to own a car like that
EB monty hey? what you gonna do with it?
Didnt pick the mazda when we bought it, but its a damm nice car either way, just not my personal preference.
Thinking about getting the EB back on the road sometime soon (Started first time a few years back after sitting for a year or soo), its an old hilux and a pain to drive, only ended up with it cause we kinda inherited it.
Might even convert it to LPG !!
On topic, what kind of fuckwit turns up to any funeral drunk and driving, let alone in these circumstances.
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4141 posts
Phew `ViPER`- lucky you conform to hardware's standards in the vehicle department.
Driving a Mitsu Lancer, I'm not so lucky myself. Everyday I just try to be a better person and hope that someday hardware will accept me for who I am.
|
hardware
Brisbane, Queensland
6447 posts
ahahah pinky
you know i love you despite your massive character flaws
:D
|
Pinky
Melbourne, Victoria
4146 posts
It just gets better :/ Man all the people from that circle sure seem like prime candidates for export to other countries
Haha, they look pretty friendly to me :-/
They turned on the media today.
Mourners waiting for the hearse to depart the funeral of 18-year-old Anthony Iannetta angrily confronted members of the media and other onlookers, including local residents and people passing by.
Young men in black left the St Francis of Assisi Church, crossed a road and walked threateningly towards journalists until friends and police helped diffuse the situation.
The group, which numbered more than 50, told reporters and cameramen to ‘‘f--- off’’ and ‘‘show some respect’’.
"You’re lucky I don’t f-----g bash you,’’ a young woman yelled at a cameraman.
Another journalist was told to ‘‘f--- off’’ or he would have his camera smashed.
Media are pretty bloody annoying though, but seriously, bang 5 peeps into a tree and they are bound to hang around.
|
fpot
Gold Coast, Queensland
16982 posts
Someone should scatter the crash site with empty beer bottles instead of flowers.
|
tequila
Brisbane, Queensland
5481 posts
I would lose 0 sleep if every media related person in the world dropped dead right this second
journos are scum, media reports what it wants regardless of the facts and they are generally responsible for a lot of evil in the world
|
fpot
Gold Coast, Queensland
16983 posts
What about if one of those media people were piloting a plane on a collision course with your house? What then?????
|
taggs
Brisbane, Queensland
3550 posts
Bah
Brisbane, Queensland
3497 posts
Someone should scatter the crash site with empty beer bottles instead of flowers. Pretty sure that's what they are doing.
The tree is adorned with floral tributes, as well as an Australian flag, bottles of Jim Beam, cigarette packets and football scarves.
|
konstie
Melbourne, Victoria
410 posts
Someone should scatter the crash site with empty beer bottles instead of flowers. Pretty sure that's what they are doing.
The tree is adorned with floral tributes, as well as an Australian flag, bottles of Jim Beam, cigarette packets and football scarves.
yay white trash.
chick is hot thought.
|
mission
Brisbane, Queensland
6200 posts
Go find her, you might get her on the rebound.
|
This thread is archived and cannot be replied to.
|